designed by nitin    
 


 

Volume:6,Number:9                                                                                    5    September 2005

 

Environment

 

 

Ozone depletion, climate change plaque Antarctica

1

 

From global warming to climate change

1-2

 

Erratic monsoon a fallout of global climate change

2

 

Climate change adds to Africa’s woes

3

 

The fuel of the future

3-5

 

Environment is a political tool in TN

5-6

 

Environment policy under wraps

6-7

 

Envisat images show major ozone loss over Antarctica

7

 

Gases regulated under the Kyoto Protocol

7-8

 

Carbon credit definitely spells “Gold’ in the modern world

8-10

 

Andhra policy doesn’t stop litigation

10-11

 

Lessons from Mithi make Maharashtra more aware

11-12

 

Loss of soil carbon “will speed global warming”

12-13

 

Irrigation projects have ecological costs

13-14

 

वायुमंडल में घातक गैसों को कम करने के लिए स्वच्छ विकास प्रक्रिया पर जोर

14-15

 

ग्लोबल वार्मिंग से हिमालयी नदियों में जलाभाव का खतरा

15

 

समुद्री तापमान में वृद्धि से बढ़े तूफान के खतरे

16

Pollution

 

 

Junk petrol for ethanol

17-18

 

Experts demand ‘green courts,’ given Orissa’s record

18-19

 

Kerala uses persuasion to try and cleanse its act

19-20

 

Mathura bans polythene bags

20-21

 

How best to beat plastic boom

21

 

Plastic law has no penalty claws

22

 

Biomedical waste polluting environment

22-23

 

Pollution board norms for idol immersion

24

 

No relaxation of noise pollution norms

24-25

 

Cleaning Yamuna not an easy task for center

26

Forestry

 

 

Traditional knowledge a legal and market conundrum

27-28

 

Preserve, protect and promote

28-30

 

Forestry project boosts development

30

 

World bank nod to forestry project soon

30-31

 

More rights to states in forest conservation sought

31

 

Green Doon may soon become a memory

32

 

Sweet Stevia hot mong herbal farmers

33

 

Campaign launched for biological control of a dangerous weed

33-34

Wildlife

 

 

Sibal wants Crab in endangered list

35

 

Mahseer facing extinction

35-36

 

Chilka dolphins in peril

36

 

India tightens surveillance against Avian influenza

36-37

 

House sparrow on verge of extinction

37

 

Vulture breeding center runs into trouble

38-39

 

Farm chirus, save shahtoosh

39-40

 

Is musk deer going the sariska tiger way?

41

 

Orissa to set up community reserve for blackbucks

42

 

Elephants in the mist

42-44

 

Relocate tigers to sariska, says Rajasthan panel

44-45

 

Sariska to get back big cats

45-46

 

Curb human activity near sariska: panel

46

 

WII to conduct nationwide tiger census from November

47

 

Indian tiger skins flooding Tibet blackmarket

47-48

 

Tiger census may spring surprises

48-49

 

Uneasy existence

50-51

 

For claws, lions being poisoned in gir forest

51-52

 

Roar of lions in land of bandits

52-53

 

A jewel crafted by nature

53-54

 

Haryana seeks Rs. 28 lakh for wildlife census

55

 

कभी भारत में भी उछल-कूद करते थे कंगारू

56

Information Pertaining to ICFRE, Its Institutes and Centres

 

 

State gets exotic tree from China

57

 

वन अनुसंधान संस्थान में हाई टैक नर्सरी व प्लांटेशन मैनेजमेंट ट्रेनिंग कोर्स शुरू

57-58

 

वन संरक्षण में लोग भागीदारी निभाएं

58

Workshop, Training and Seminar

 

 

Green building technology should reach all

59

 


Ozone Depletion, Climate Change Plaque Antarctica
 Vijay Pandhi

“Efforts should be continued to ensure that commercial activities will not impact on the successes of the Antarctic Treaty system, in particular in securing Antarctica as a natural reserve, devoted to peace and science, says Mr. Annan in a report detailing the progress of the Treaty. In particular he notes that “illegal, unregulated and unreported fishing for toothfish in the Southern Ocean still exceeds reported catches despite major efforts to address such activities.” Other major areas of concern are the increase in tourism over the last 10 years, and the emerging threat of bioprospecting which is on the rise. During 2003-04, illegal, unregulated and unreported toothfish fishing was estimated at 15,992 tons, up from 13,804 in 2000-01. The number of captured seals was also up from 2001 to 3,709, even though not all countries cooperating with the 1998 Madrid Protocol, which governs protection and management, had reported their activities. There was also a huge increase of 308 percent in ship-borne tourists to the Antarctic Peninsula since 1993, up to 27,324 in 2004-5,  from  6,704  in 1992-3.
           An increase in high-risk, adventure tourism has also wrought havoc on the region, creating the need for new search and rescue missions and country liability assessments. “Global changes, in particular climate change and the depletion of the ozone layer, remain major threats,” the report says. Several glaciers including Brown Glacier on Heard Island, and Collins Glacier on King George Island have retreated by several metres over three years, providing evidence of continued glacial melting. A ripple effect has impacted animals in the area, with reductions in the breeding of three seabird species correlated with increases in sea temperature and the loss of penguin nests correlating to a decline in krill due to retreating pack ice. These developments came despite “unique” international cooperation, “in particular in connection with the study of global changes,” the positive introduction of a Secretariat in 2004 to head the effort, and the opening or upgrading of nine stations to monitor the state of the region, according to the report.
The Himachal Times (Dehradun), 14 Sep.2005


The earth’s atmosphere acts as a filter for the solar rays. Approximately half the visible light and ultraviolet radiation given off by the sun is either absorbed by various layers or reflected back into space. Most of the 50% of rays, which do get through heat the earth’s surface. These are eventually reflected back into space as infrared radiation. This ‘greenhouse’ effect is the atmospheric trapping of that infrared radiation, which is a natural phenomenon without which the earth would be a really cold place and un-inhabitable for man. When carbon-based fuels are burned, greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide are given off. These add to the layer that is permeable to ultraviolet but not infrared radiation. As more and more fossil fuels are burned, the layer of greenhouse gases thickens. Solar radiation continues to pass through unimpeded while the heat that is reflected from the earth finds it harder and harder to escape into space.  In the medium to long term, this will result in the gradual increase in the earth’s temperature. This is known as global warming.           However, just to complicate the story some more, global climatic changes are not predictable. In fact, they are hugely unpredictable. Hence, the global climate’s response  to   an   increase   in   the  carbon dioxide emission levels  has  lead  to  a  re-phrasing of the term ‘global warming’. It is today called ‘global climate change’.           
         There are two-fold contributing factors to climate change. Simultaneously, they trap reflected heat and thin protective ozone layer. This ozone depletion reduces the atmosphere’s ability to absorb and reflect solar radiation. As a result, more solar radiation is able to reach the earth’s surface and potentially accelerate the process of climate change. Climate change is a global problem requiring action from the entire international community. Countries from around the world are working together.
The Economic Times (New Delhi), 05 Sep.2005


Unprecedented floods in Mumbai; dry spell in June followed by a wet July; and again a dry August. If you thought this year’s monsoon has behaved erratically, you are spot on. Some experts are viewing this as a fallout of the change in global climate. This erratic trend in monsoon has also impacted upon the area coverages under different khariff (summer) crops across the country. It also led to delayed sowing at places.               Similar variability in weather pattern is also felt elsewhere. In the US this year, there are regions of drought and wet areas. The recent occurrence of Katrina has brought into fore the issue of global climate change.  The       National       Oceanic    and Atmospheric Administration (N.O.A.A), which made a forecast for Altantic hurricane much before the occurrence of Katrina, admits the variability in weather patterns. It said it is very difficult to predict hurricanes at extended ranges as they are “often related to daily weather patterns rather than seasonal climate patterns”. The UK government’s chief scientific advisor, David King says: “The increased intensity of hurricanes is associated with global climate change.”  The seasonal ozone hole over Antartica has widened sharply this year, making it the biggest since the year 2000 and the third largest on record according to the European Space Agency.
The Financial Express (New Delhi), 05 Sep.2005


  Climate Change Adds to Africa’s Woes
 John Madeley

Efforts to alleviate poverty in Africa will fail unless urgent action is taken to halt climate change, a group of Western development and environmental agencies has said. Acting collectively as the Working Group on Climate Change and Development, a coalition of 21 agencies says the poorest people on the planet are being hardest hit by global warming as land becomes uncultivable and pests and disease threaten livestock.  In its report, the coalition, which includes Action Aid, Christian Aid, Friends of the Earth, and the New Economics Foundation, says climate change threatens to leave an additional 80-120 million people worldwide hungry and, although, it was one of the main items on the G8 agenda in Scotland last month the G8, says the coalition, did nothing and it is Africa that will pay the price.   It says vital rains are already disrupted with serious consequences for the 70% of Africans who rely on rain-fed farming as opposed to agricultural enterprises serviced by irrigation. These rain-reliant farmers are over-whelmingly from the poorest families and the fear is that livelihoods built for generations on particular patterns of farming may become unviable. Sixty-five    developing   countries, home to more than half the developing world’s total population, risk losing about 280 million tones of potential cereal production as a result of climate change. This loss is equivalent to 16% of the agricultural gross domestic product of these countries in 1995. The severest impact could be in sub-Saharan African countries as they are the least able to adapt to climate change or to compensate for it through increased food imports. Against this backdrop the coalition’s report, “Africa: Up in Smoke?” not only calls for rich countries to go beyond their Kyoto carbon emission targets and make even greater cuts in their greenhouse gas emissions but also to make significantly more money available to help poor countries adapt to the world’s changing weather pattern.             
          Two years ago, the former chief executive of the UK’s Meteorological Office, John Houghton, said he had no hesitation in describing global warming as a weapon of mass destruction and the present chair of the FAO’s Interdepartmental Working Group on Climate, Wulf Killmann, has pointed out that changes in the world’s weather will not only affect plant life but will also have an impact on animal health as well.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 02 Sep.2005


The Fuel of the Future
 Tutu Dhawan

Ever since the oil crisis of the mid-Seventies shook up the entire world, most developed countries as well as leading car manufacturers had thought of producing alternative fuels that could keep the wheels moving. If the most important ingredient that propels the automobile is in jeopardy then who in the world is going to buy an automobile? This was the question that came up before automobile manufacturers and while some of them were pessimistic the others were left to the fait accompli. However, there were the dedicated ones who started doing their home work a bit more seriously and came up with various alternatives such as ethanol, methanol, Liquefied gases, compressed natural gas, hydrogen, electricity, fuel cells and many others that are still being tested by scientists and car manufacturers of the world. Till date no fuel other than the two fossil fuels – petrol and diesel – has been found that is equally well suited for the conventional internal combustion engine. It is also convenient and efficient to make the engines run at peak performance and yet keep a sort of balance with the ecology without additives and catalysts at the final stage of the exhaust gas.  After a decade of research Daimler Chrysler in collaboration with the University of Hohenheim in Germany and the Central Salt and Marine Chemicals Research Institute in India headed by Pushpito K. Ghosh have come out with a near normal bio-diesel alternative to the conventional diesel. This fuel comes from a small nut like fruit of a fully grown bush about eight feet tall. The “jatropha” takes about two years to mature. The nut is taken apart and the seeds are crushed in a sort of oil a ‘modern’ village ‘kohlu’ (oil expeller). The oil from the seed is then processed and refined and this is the bio-diesel. In India the bio-diesel project has been running in the semiarid and non-productive lands of Gujarat and Orissa for more than three years now under the guidance of CSMCRI.                        
          Indian project
When in full swing, this scheme will prove to be a boon to millions of poor farmers in semi and totally arid areas. The jatropha crop grown on such farmlands will not hamper the usual cropping pattern, on the other hand it can provide additional income to the farmers. Of the estimated 130 million hectares of wasteland in India about 33 million are still available for reclamation through tree plantation, according to Planning Commission figures. The ‘test-phase of the bio-diesel project has involved running an unmodified C-class Mercedes-Benz on bio-diesel for over 25,000 kilometers till date and the ‘acid test’ was to run successfully three such vehicles (two ‘C’ class and one seven seater Vianovan) from the Pune works of Daimler Chrysler to the world’s highest motorable road at 18,380 feet above sea level at Khardungla in Kashmir through the frozen and highest desert in the world. These tests have demonstrated the viability of bio-diesel as a suitable alternative to conventional fuels, especially in the Indian context. Through this trial run CSMCRI and Daimler Chrysler are now making improvements in its emission properties and removing anti-freezing glitches. The road test is expected to offer valuable findings with respect to the characteristics of bio-diesel under demanding terrain and weather conditions. The fuel has been found to have better ‘octane’ rating that improves engine performance by 20% over the conventional diesel and can be used in any diesel fired engine – even in the most primitive diesel engine with no pre-heater for starting, a tractor or power generating diesel generating set. Bio-diesel ignites better and burns up to 70% cleaner, has much better lubricating properties, extends engine life.            
          It has been recorded in Germany that a truck ran more than 1.25 million kilometers on bio-diesel before it was opened for an overhaul. It reduces substantially toxic emissions, and being plant based, does not add CO2 to the atmosphere. The ozone depleting potential of the exhaust gases is less than half that of its fossil counterpart. Bio-diesel can be produced   from   any  fat  of  vegetable  or waste oil and can be easily stored and transported as its flash point is 157 against 54 of conventional diesel. Its cost after allowing for the value  of  all  by  products works out to Rs. 27 a litre before taxes. (Oxygen supplied to the global atmosphere is an added benefit). It is forecast that by 2020 bio-diesel will be able to meet up to 20% of India’s diesel consumption. This is a very optimistic outlook indeed.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 19 Sep.2005


  Environment is a Political Tool in TN
 
Vackayil Joseph

Environment protection is a tool in the hands of the politician and the Tamil Nadu government. If the powers that be want a project to come up, environment norms are given short shrift. If the higher authority does not like a project or its key proponents, the environment issue is invoked and the project is opposed. The state’s pollution control board is often caught in the political and bureaucratic tangle. A case in point is the Rs 2,427 crore Sethusamudram project, being implemented by the Union government. Chief minister J. Jayalalithaa is still not convinced of its environmental viability and wants it to be shelved. She wants more studies to be undertaken before its implementation.  However, Union shipping and road transport minister T.R. Baalu is determined to complete the project on schedule. He assures, “there would be no environmental impact from the project. All necessary studies have been done and the required safeguards taken. A need-based protective system would be in place so save the marine ecology and biodiversity.”    At present, there aren’t too many environmental issues in the forefront in TN, as most investments are in the relatively clean automotive and IT sectors. For leather and textile processing, the traditional polluters, specialized parks with pollution control devices are being planned.            In the mid-1990s, willing to go an extra mile to win investors, the state had even welcomed industrial projects denied entry elsewhere on grounds of pollution. But they had to face citizens’ wrath. Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) are an active force here.   Dupont (which shifted its project to TN after giving up on Goa) had to drop its original plan to produce nylon rope at its manufacturing project near Chennai. Sterlite’s copper smelter plant at Tuticorin (it came here after facing protests in Ratnagiri, Maharashtra) had to put in place adequate investment to make the plant environment friendly. But NGOs say industries have already done the damage. The state’s major rivers and water systems are already polluted. Vast stretches of agricultural land have been degraded because of industrial effluence and solid waste. They say the government is simply avoiding responsibility by setting up authorities’ and ‘boards’ with very little powers. “The state pollution control board is legalistic and ritualistic in its action. It has   very   little   transparency. The Board does not even reveal the findings of a public hearing. It will not disclose the sources and materials it depends on to clear a project and declare  it  ecologically viable,” says Ozie Fernandes, a leading environmental activist and leader of several NGO networks.
The Financial Express (New Delhi), 19 Sep.2005


  Environment Policy Under Wraps
 
Pankaj Sekhsaria and Ashish Kothari

Some things die hard. Despite the wide spread agreement within and outside the government on the citizens’ right to information, some sections of the government persist with an atmosphere of secrecy. Baffling as it may sound, the latest manifestation is the ministry of environment and forests draft of the National Environment Policy, just finalised, but not available to the public.   In the last few months, the media debated issues related to the environment, forests and wildlife, notably the proposed Scheduled Tribes (Recognition of Forest Rights) Bill 2005 and the report of the Tiger Task Force (TTF) that was recently submitted to the prime minister. While the context and content of these two documents have been a source of serious differences, it has been heartening that these have been discussed in an open and transparent manner. The TTF in particular has come for a lot of appreciation for the open, consultative and transparent way in which the process was carried out and that the entire report made available to the public. While there was some concern initially on the Forest Rights Bill, this too was made a public document when the issue was raised by a cross-section of people working on issues related to the forests.  However, for the last few months, the ministry of environment and forests has been working on finalising the National Environment Policy (NEP). It is ‘reported’ to have also submitted a final draft to the prime minister nearly two weeks ago for his endorsement before it is taken to the cabinet for approval. Shocking as it might sound, not only has the draft been kept away from the public, it has even been marked secret on every page.  In October 2004, more than 90 environmental and special groups from the country had collectively raised serious concerns about the initial version of the NEP. They had approached the National Advisory Council (NAC) calling for a new and participatory process for drafting the policy. There was a feeling that NEP was too anthropocentric and economistric in its approach, and was directed at making the environment subservient to wealth generating activities and sectors. It was also felt that the NEP actually fell short of making a policy statement, did not even clearly state its long term vision, or its relation to other policies of the government. And there was also the issue of the absence of a participatory and consultative process for its drafting.  Concern was especially raised that discussions had been held with industry groups but local communities, who are the ones most directly dependent on the environment and most affected by its destruction, were not consulted at all.  These inputs and the call for consultations were resisted by the environment ministry, particularly when it came to having discussions with the non-governmental organisations, the people and community groups. Following the intervention of the NAC, however, some consultations did occur, raising the hope that the process and the final outcome would be a more democratic one. That clearly has been belied. That the new draft of the policy should now be marked secret only indicates that the approach of the environment ministry has only become more regressive. In fact, even the NAC has not been informed about this new draft of the NEP. A   member  of   the NAC   was recently sent a letter by the environment ministry stating that the ministry had no intentions of making it public. One   can   only    wonder     whose national environment policy it really is. What serious threat can it pose to national security for it to be a secret document? It has once again been left for members in civil society, individuals and organisations to bring the matter to the notice of the prime minister and request for corrective action; over 60 organisations and individuals have now addressed an open letter to him to this effect. The deepest darkness, it is said, is found right underneath the lamp the lights up the room. A government committed to the citizens’ right to information would do well by starting in its very own backyard.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 09 Sep.2005


New readings from the European satellite Envisat suggest that this year’s southern hemisphere ozone hole may be one of the largest on record. The hole covers an area of 10-million sq. km – approximately the same size as Europe. According to BBC, it is expected to continue expanding for two to three weeks.  There have been signs over the last two years that damage to  the  ozone  layer has reduced, but a full recovery is not expected until around 2050. The data comes from the Scanning Imaging Absorption Spectrometer for Atmospheric Chartography on board Envisat, launched in 2002 and operated by the European Space Agency (ESA). They show that the Antarctic ozone hole was larger in mid-August this year than at the same period in any year since 2000, BBC said.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 01 Sep.2005


  Gases Regulated Under the Kyoto Protocol

The Kyoto Protocol has regulated the use of six gases, which is not to say that others are not harmful. There are another 25 gases, which qualify, having been identified as climate changing greenhouse gases. However, the six gases have been targeted since they are released in sufficient quantities to justify their regulation. Water vapour is another very important greenhouse gas but this is outside the control of humankind.             The six gases regulated are: carbondioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), hydrofluorocarbons (HFC5), perfluorocarbons (PFC5), sulphur hexafluoride (SF6).             
           CO2
comes from the decay of materials, respiration of plant and animal life, volcanic and thermal venting, natural and human induced combustion of materials and fuels. Photosynthesis and ocean absorption remove it.             Methane is a more effective heat trapping gas. It comes from the decay of matter without the presence of oxygen. The primary sources of methane are wetlands, rice paddies, animal digestive processes, fossil fuel extraction and decaying garbage.  

          Nitrous oxide
the natural source for this is from soils and oceans. Humans contribute through soil cultivation and use of nitrogen fertilizer, nylon production, burning of organic matter and fossil fuels.
          HFC and PFC:
halocarbons are human produced chemical compounds containing members of the halogen family (bromine, chlorine and fluorine) and carbon. These are some of the most effective heat trapping greenhouse gases of all. Most of these are regulated under the Montreal Protocol (for the protection of the ozone layer). Newer gases are ozone friendly but greenhouse unfriendly. Hence the Kyoto Protocol regulation.                  
           SF6
is emitted by electric power industry in circuit breakers, gas insulation substations and switchgear. This industry uses a significant percentage of the 6,500-7,000 metric tones of SF6 produced annually globally.
The Economic Times (New Delhi), 05 Sep.2005


  Carbon Credit Definitely Spells “Gold’ in the Modern World

It’s cash with a capital C. Several companies from the developing world including India are singing paeans to the Kyoto Protocol which is likely to see several non-polluting industries bring home the bacon. Little wonder companies within the renewable energy space (wind, solar, biomass, hydel, geothermal) such as NEPC and IFSL (treatment of solid waste) have witnessed buying interests in their respective scrips. And they are not the only ones. Co-generation companies in steel (Jindals), sugar (Balrampur), power and those switching from fossil fuels to natural gases have also begun attracting attention as they are the ones to benefit from this Protocol through carbon credits. Just what is the Protocol all about and what are these carbon credits? The growing concern for the change in the climatic conditions the worldover has given rise to the legally binding Kyoto Protocol. The main aim of this international agreement is to reduce the emission of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, sulfur hexafluoride, hydroflurocarbons and perflurocarbons. Bulk of the emission is from the industrialized countries in the European Union, the US and Japan. During 2008-2012, they have to reduce their collective emission of greenhouse gases by 5.2% of what it was in 1990. Each signatory country is required to demonstrate progressively in reducing the set emission targets within the commitment period. The ratification of the protocol has paved the way for trading in carbon credits across the world on several exchanges.Just how does the mechanism work? To put it simply, carbon credits are certificates issued to countries which reduce the emissions of greenhouse gases that deplete the atmosphere’s ozone layer leading to global warming. Surplus carbon credits can be sold in the market. For example, a reduction of one tonne of carbon dioxide emission fetches one credit certificate. Those countries/companies which fall short on their prescribed emission targets have to make do by buying these credits from surplus carbon credit holders.              To facilitate trading of these instruments, the UK Emissions Trading System, the New South Wales trading system and the Chicago Climate Exchange are places where credits change hands. In 2003, 78 million tones of carbon credits were traded. In 2004, transaction in carbon credit rose 38% to 107 million tones. The weighted average price of each credit is around $4.22. A secondary market for these carbon credits has also emerged. There are several funds which buy credits at a lower price to be able to trade at a higher price later. Such mechanisms can be availed of by project developers, who need the funds to develop the projects. Trades in the trading exchanges were priced between 7 and 9 Euros in 2004. However, according to industry sources, this increased to 17 Euros in April 2005. These sources say that carbon credit price is likely to rise once the US becomes a signatory to the protocol. America, the largest emitter of greenhouse gases accounting for more than a third of the greenhouse gases emitted in the world, has been shying away from signing the protocol. But sooner or later, the country will have to fall in line with the world, which would push up demand and thereby carbon credit prices.  The buyers would be largely from the developed world. In the January-April 2005 period, the major buyers were European countries and Japan with the former accounting for 60% of the credit purchases. Interestingly, Netherlands was the largest buyer accounting for about 16% of the total pie.            
          The sellers of carbon credit would be from developing countries largely from the Asian region, including India. Asia accounted for 45% of the total carbon credits sold followed by Latin America with 35%. The three largest suppliers of carbon credits are India, Brazil and Chile with India, by far being the largest carbon credit supplier with a 31% market share in the world. Currently, about eight or nine greenhouse gas reducing projects in the world have got the nod from the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), the nodal agency, to trade in carbon credits. Though carbon credits market is still in its, infancy, there is no doubt that the market is bound to grow by leaps and bounds. Also given the supply-demand dynamics, prices of carbon credits may hit the roof in the short term. The Indian industry has shown great enthusiasm in putting up Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) projects and the NCA (the National CDM Authority) in India has approved about 90 such projects as on June 2005. Majority of them are in the renewable energy and energy efficiency categories. Thus, India has emerged as a front-runner in the emerging business of carbon credit trading. Though carbon credit trading holds immense promise, there are a few drawbacks in terms of the US still being out of the ambit of the Protocol and the fact that things are not clear as to what will happen post first phase (2008-2012) of the protocol. Also though the emission targets have been fixed at the national levels of the signatory countries, it is not clear how it would be implemented at the grassroot level in terms of emission reduction levels between various industries. As always, any new change brings with it some   element   of confusion   but once the ball gets rolling, the carbon credit market, a new animal, would bring in a lot of moolah for the new generation industries. Various studies have estimated the total market size for  CDM  between  5 crore tones of CO2 to 45 crore tones. If one takes the base price of 5 Euros per tonne of CO2, this translates into 25 crore Euros going up to 225 crore Euros. So much for keeping the environment clean. Little wonder, some of the Indian beneficiaries from the corporate world are breathing easy
.
The Economic Times (New Delhi), 14 Sep.2005


  Andhra Policy doesn’t Stop Litigation
 Naagesh Satya

Andra Pradesh (AP) is yet to come to terms with balancing development and environment. Through the popular principle of ‘polluter pays’ exists, a number of legal disputes languish in the courts, stalling the progress of projects. In some cases, the environment issue is being used as a tool to create hurdles.     Interestingly, the state has in place an environment policy, included as a separate chapter in the Vision 2020 document of the Chandrababu Naidu government. “It is more focused than the Centre’s environment policy,” says a senior state environment department official. Despite abundant natural resources, no major manufacturing project was set up in the state in the past two decades. The Naidu government failed in its attempt to set up quartz and bauxite mining and related manufacturing units, as environmentalists raised a hue and cry and even dragged the state to courts, saying that it would take way the rights of tribals in the eastern ghats. The present Congress government is reviving some of these projects. It has signed an MoU with the Jindal group to set up an aluminum project near Visakhapatnam and to mine bauxite ore concentrated in the forests of the AP-Orissa border. The original project was an integrated one (from mining to production of aluminium). But the activities have now been separated and the major share of mining activity is held by a government corporation. Another uranium project proposed for Nalgonda district is still mired in environmental problems, even though the government has conducted public hearings twice in the area. Interestingly, even when villagers concerned are willing to vacate, NGOs are voicing their protest through dharnas.  Importantly, the fundamental issue is still not being addressed. “Cost benefit analysis for any project should include ecological costs. That is not being done even now,” says an official. “Green accounting should be done in any case. In fact, the institute of Cost and Work Accountants of India has suitable models for infrastructure projects,” points out Tishya Chatterjee, principal secretary, environment, forests, science and technology. He clarifies that in the case of the older and prestigious Polavaram and Pulichinthala irrigation projects, environment clearances have been sought and received from the central government.What is interesting is that the other 44 projects announced by the government are untouched. Clearly, vested political interest groups use the environment card to stall projects. On the other side, the governments of the day seem in a hurry to set up and  clear   projects   without   much attention to the environment costs. “There is no doubt they are in a hurry,” says an official.                                              Recently, in a bid to ease traffic congestion in    some   arterial   roads,   themunicipal commissioner of   
         Hyderabad ordered felling of trees destroying natural formations to widen roads. While NGOs argue that road widening can be done without cutting trees, a senior environment official feels that as long as the municipal corporation compensates by planting enough number of trees on alternative sites, these can be allowed in the larger public interest.
The Financial Express (New Delhi), 19 Sep.2005


  Lessons from Mithi Make Maharashtra More Aware
 Sanjay Jog

Maharashtra, which still continues to maintain its preeminence in attracting domestic and foreign direct investment, had to cut a sorry figure when its commercial capital Mumbai remained inaccessible after the recent floods and waterlogging. A key factor was the manner in which industry here has been allowed to grow at considerable environment cost. The Mithi River, which originates from north Mumbai, stands encroached by several infrastructure projects, industrial and residential establishments, thanks to the government’s criminal apathy. Despite warnings by NEERI and the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board (MPCB) about the possibility of floods due to diversion of the Mithi river, the state government, the civic body and other agencies failed to initiate any action. It is only now that the government has launched an ambitious Mithi river development programme, for which the high court has ordered speedy implementation.  This is not the lone example wherein the government and its agencies have prima facie compromised on protecting the environment. In case of redevelopment of Mumbai’s textile mill lands, the High Court had to direct MPCB to carry out a detailed survey to find whether or not the mills had followed the pollution control norms. Of the 56 mills, MPCB had to ask six to stop construction work that had been launched without seeking its prior approval. As many as 12 mills had not bothered to seek MPCB’s consent and the mandatory environment clearances under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.  Moreover, it was the high Court that intervened at the encroachment, allegedly by certain developers and builders on the ailing mangroves. In rural Maharashtra too, alert citizens had to approach the courts to seek directives for initiating action against polluting industrial units and for discontinuation of haphazard development on green zones. Villagers in Thane district were relieved only when the government and its agencies had to relook into the alleged usage of underground water by a soft drink manufacturing unit.    “The state has stepped up its efforts to deal with laxity in the implementation of pollution control norms,” says MPCB’s member secretary, DB Boralkar. MPCB had recently served notices seeking to initiate action against 56 industrial units in the chemical zone of Lote Parshuram in the Konkan region.
          Similar notices were also issued against units in the industrial areas of Dombivli and Ambernath (in Thane district). The Board also followed up on the implementation     of     common    effluent treatment plants in the industrial estates of Tarapur, Thane-Belapur, Ambernath, Roha, Mahad, Lote Parshuram, Taloja and Patalganga. “There have been no cases of groundwater pollution due to discharges from any unit. MPCB is quite alert,” concludes Mr. Boralkar.
The Financial Express (New Delhi), 19 Sep.2005


England’s soils have been losing carbon at the rate of four million tones a year for the past 25 years – losses which will accelerate global warming and which have already offset all the cuts in Britain’s industrial carbon emissions between 1990 and 2002, scientists have warned. The research dashes hopes that more carbon dioxide emissions might mean more vegetation growth and therefore more carbon removed from the atmosphere.     The unexpected loss of carbon from the soils – consistently, everywhere in England and Wales and therefore probably everywhere in the temperate world – means more carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, which means even more global warming, and yet more carbon lost from the soil.              
           “All the consequences of global warming will occur more rapidly. That’s the scary thing: the amount of time we have got to do something about it is smaller than we thought,” Guy Kirk, of Cranfield University, told the British Association Festival of Science, in Dublin. He and colleagues sampled the top 15 centimeters of soil at almost 6,000 fixed points in England and Wales between 1978 and 2003, to measure the changes in living and decaying matter locked in pastures, croplands, forests, bogs, scrubland and heaths.                                           
         Their findings, published in Nature on Thursday, show that carbon was being lost from the soil at an average of 0.6 percent a year: the richer the soils, the higher the rate of loss. When the figures were extrapolated to include all of the U.K., the annual loss was 13 million tones. There was no single factor other than global warming that could explain such changes in non-agricultural soils, they said.    In the past 25 years the average temperature has increased by half a degree centigrade and the growing season of the northern hemisphere has been extended by almost 11 days. Warmer soils will have encouraged greater microbial activity, so more rapid decay of organic matter in the soil, leading to greater discharges of gases. For over two decades, scientists have tried to calculate the earth’s annual carbon flow. Some of the carbon is absorbed by the oceans, to be trapped as limestone; some is locked in soil as peat or stored in woodland. Latest research implies that in a warmer world much of this “lost” carbon will find its way back into the atmosphere more quickly.  The study confirms the value of long-term research: the national soil inventory   was   established   in  1978 as a network of fixed points at intervals of three miles, and the scientists used went on using the same techniques to measure the changes in soil carbon over more than 20 years.  Professor Kirk said: “It had been reckoned  that  the Co2  fertilisation  effect was somehow offsetting about 25 percent of the direct human induced carbon dioxide emissions. It was reckoned that the soil temperature emission effect would catch up in maybe 10 to 50 years’ time. We are showing that it seems to be happening rather faster than that.”
The Hindu (New Delhi), 09 Sep.2005


While talking about irrigation projects, one aspect that gets relegated to second place is the ecological cost of such activities. Improperly planned irrigation projects have led to disruption in the regions served. The most prominent and noticeable effects of unplanned irrigation projects have been changes in the ground water level, soil salinity changes and water logging. Other effects include subsidence of land, changes in the ecological system and spread of water borne diseases. According to data from IWMI, surface water is used to irrigate nearly 21 million hectares of farm-land in India and almost 27 million hectares are irrigated using ground water. This assured supply of water has brought about benefits like reduced dependence on monsoons due to better control over the irrigation supply to crops. At the same time, unplanned and haphazard usage of these resources has led to ecological crisis in several parts of the country.                                                     
         The problems created due to large surface water projects include water logging, reduction in fresh water flow, pollution concentration and destruction of fisheries. Water projects are also known to increase the incidence of water borne diseases. Prominent among these are malaria and filariasis. Excessive and indiscriminate usage of groundwater results in problems like salinity, depletion of water table and subsidence of land. As the ground water level goes down, it causes vegetation in the region to suffer throwing the local biosystem out of gear. Salinity can turn vast tracts of land unfit for cultivation.                                           
        Data from Ministry of Water Resources shows that salinity has increased in several regions of India due to improper water resource usage. States like Andhra Pradesh, Orissa, West Bengal and Gujarat have been effected by excess ground water salinity. This is attributed to the incursion of salt water into the natural underground acquifiers. Parts of Maharashtra, Bihar, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan have been affected by excess salinity in the soil, caused due to evaporation of water from the soil surface leaving behind the dissolved minerals and salts.                                                     
         Haryana, Punjab, Western Uttar Pradesh   and    Central    Tamil  Nadu  are showing symptoms of overexploitation of groundwater. In regions like North Gujarat, Tamil Nadu, Saurashtra and Southern Rajasthan the situation has detriorated to such an extent that it has led to decline of agricultural activity.
The Economic Times (New Delhi), 07 Sep.2005


  वायुमंडल में घातक गैसों को कम करने के लिए स्वच्छ विकास प्रक्रिया पर जोर
 रवीन्द्र देवलियाल

वायुमंडल में ग्रीन हाऊस गैसों का प्रभाव कम करने और ग्लोबल वार्मिंग को रोकने के लिये उत्तरांचल सरकार व इस क्षेत्र से जुड़े वैज्ञानिकों ने कमर कस ली है। वैज्ञानिक इस क्षेत्र में काम करने के लिए उत्साहित है लेकिन अंतर्राष्ट्रीय स्तर पर निर्धारित कड़े मानकों व लंबी प्रक्रिया के चलते उन्हें कड़े पापड़ बेलने पड़ रहे हैं। वैज्ञानिकों का अभिमत है कि वन बहुल उत्तरांचल राज्य में वानिकी के क्षेत्र में बेहतर प्रयासों के चलते वायुमंडल में बढ़ रही घातक गैसों के प्रभाव को कुछ हद तक कम किया जा सकता है और विकसित देशों के लिये एक कड़ी नजर पेश कर बहुमूल्य डालर भी कमाये जा सकते हैं।                
          
वैज्ञानिकों का मत है कि ग्लोबल वार्मिंग की समस्या विश्व समुदाय के लिये एक चुनौती बनकर उभर रही है। इसका असर ध्रुवीय क्षेत्रों के साथ ही हिमाच्छादित ग्लेशियरों पर भी पड़ रहा है और वायुमंडल में ग्रीन हाऊस (घातक) गैसों के बढ़ने से तापमान में लगातार बढ़ोत्तरी होती जा रही है। इसके कारण ग्लेशियर पिघलते जा रहे हैं। वे असंतुलित विकास को इसका प्रमुख कारण मानते हैं और खासकर विकसित देशों को इसके लिए अधिक जिम्मेदार मानते हैं।           
             
उनका मानना है कि वायुमंडल में कार्बनडाइआक्साइड, सल्फरडाइआक्साइड, कार्बनमोनोक्साइड, मीथेन जैसी खतरनाक गैसों का प्रभाव बढ़ता जा रहा है। इससे वायुमंडल का ताप प्रभावित हो रहा है। वायुमंडल का तापमान बढ़ने से ग्लेशियरों पर खतरा मंडराता जा रहा है और ग्लेशियरों के पिघलने से समुद्रों का स्तर ऊंचा उठने की संभावना जतायी जा रही है। परिणामस्वरूप तटीय क्षेत्रों के अस्तित्व को भी संकट हो सकता है। समुद्रों का स्तर बढ़ने से तटीय क्षेत्रों में मौजूद शहरों व जनजीवन पर डूबने का खतरा हो सकता है। क्योटों संधि इसी की एक बानगी है और इसी चिंता के रूप में वह अंतर्राष्ट्रीय फलक पर उभरकर आई है।                    
           
ग्लोबल वार्मिंग के खतरे को सभी देश शिद्दत से महसूस कर रहे है और भारत भी इससे अछूता नहीं है। विकसित देशों के लिये भारत एक नजीर पेश कर इस क्षेत्र में बेहतर प्रयोगों की कोशिश में लगा है। इसी का नतीजा है कि केन्द्र ने अधिकांश राज्यों की पर्यावरण व वानिकी के साथ ही पावर प्रोजेक्ट के क्षेत्र में बेहतर कदम उठाने के निर्देश जारी किये हैं। उत्तरांचल में इसकी अधिक विकल्प है और सरकार इसको लेकर गंभीर दिखायी दे रही है। इस प्रक्रिया के तहत उसने वानिकी और उर्जा जैसे प्रमुख क्षेत्रों में स्वच्छ विकास प्रक्रिया’ (सी.डी.एम) को अपनाने पर जोर दिया है।                   
        
प्रदेश के वैज्ञानिकों का मानना है कि भारत वानिकी व ऊर्जा के क्षेत्र में अच्छे प्रोजेक्ट तैयार कर विकसित देशों को बेच सकता है और हजारों डालर की आय कमा सकता है। उत्तरांचल ने इस प्रकार की दीर्घकालिक योजनाओं पर कवायद शुरू कर दी है। स्वच्छ विकास प्रक्रिया (सी.डी.एम) के तहत वन विभाग व वानिकी अनुसंधान एवं शिक्षा परिषद की संयुक्त टीम कुछ समय से स्थानों के चिन्हीकरण के काम में जुटी है और उसने योजना के लिये कुछ स्थानों का चिन्हीकरण का कार्य पूरा कर   लिया   है। वैज्ञानिकों   ने   नैनीताल जनपद के बेतालघाट व हल्द्वानी के गौला पार इलाके को योजना के तहत सर्वाधिक उपयुक्त पाया है। सूत्रों ने बताया कि बेहतर परिणामों के लिये मृदा व वानस्पतिक अध्ययन का कार्य जारी है। वनवर्धनिक मनोज चंद्रन ने इसकी पुष्टि करते हुए बताया कि प्रक्रिया में मौजूद कड़े प्रावधानों के तहत सभी प्रकार के समाधान किये जा रहे हैं  और  इसके पश्चात ही आवश्यक प्रोजेक्ट तैयार करने की दिशा में कदम बढ़ाया जायेगा।
हिन्दुस्तान टाइम्स (नई दिल्ली), 17 Sep.2005


वैज्ञानिकों ने वैश्विक गर्मी की गंभीरता स्पष्ट करते हुए कहा है कि यदि ग्लोबल वार्मिंग रोकने के जल्द कारगर प्रयास नहीं किये गए तो वह दिन दूर नहीं जब हिमालयी नदियों के लिए उदगम स्रोत सारे ग्लेशियर पिघल कर खत्म हो जाएंगे और भारत-पाकिस्तान की गंगा, सिंधु व ब्रह्मपुत्र नदियों में नाम मात्र का जल रहने से भारत, बांग्लादेश और पाकिस्तान में ही नहीं, चीन में भी पानी के लिए हाहाकार मच जाने वाला है। बांग्लादेश की इरावदी और चीन की यावितसी नदियों के उदगम स्रोत भी हिमालय के हिमनद-ग्लैशियर ही है जो ग्लोबल वार्मिंग की वजह से हर साल एक डिग्री सेल्सियस की बढ़ती गर्मी के कारण पिघलकर छोटे होते जा रहे हैं। इन्हीं हिम नदियों से पेयजल की आपूर्ति होती है जिनके बारे में आशंका है कि वर्ष 2010 तक ये हिमनद घटकर आधे रह जाएंगे और 2050 तक इनका अस्तित्व ही समाप्त हो जाएगा।   वैज्ञानिकों के अनुसार हिमलयी  नदियों  के पेयजल पर आश्रित भारत, पाकिस्तान, बांग्लादेश और चीन के लिए आगामी 50 वर्षों में पेयजल के अभाव का संकट पैदा हो जाने का खतरा निरंतर बढ़ता जा रहा है। तकरीबन 67% हिमनद तेजी से पिघल कर छोटे होते जा रहे हैं। गंगोत्री (गंगा का उदगम स्थल) 23 मीटर 75 फुट सालाना की दर से पिघल रहा है तो खुम्बू हिमनद तीन मील दुर तक सूख चुका है। पानी के स्रोतों-स्प्रिंग्स-तक सूख चुके हैं। हिमनद विशेषज्ञ जगदीश बहादुर के अनुसार ग्लोबल वार्मिंग का संकट निरंतर बढ़ता जा रहा है। एक वक्त था जब हिमालय पर 3 हजार हिमनद थे जिनसे पेयजल मिलता रहता था। नेपाल के हाइड्रोलौजी और मौसम विज्ञान विभाग के प्रमुख अरुण भक्त श्रेष्ठ के अनुसार हिमनदों के समाप्त हो रहे अस्तित्व से नेपाल सहित पूरे दक्षिण एशियायी इलाके में जल संकट का खतरा बढ़ने लगा है। जिस विष्णुमति नदी से नेपाल में बाढ़ आ जाया करती थी, अब वह मात्र एक नाले जैसी छोटी हो गई है।
दून दर्पण (देहरादून), 12 Sep.2005


   समुद्री तापमान में वृद्धि से बढ़े तूफान के खतरे

अमेरिका के न्यू ओरलियंस शहर में तबाह कर देने वाले कैटरीना जैसे उच्च तीव्रता श्रेणी 4 और 5 के समुद्री तूफानों की संख्या पिछले 35 वर्षों में दोगुनी हो गई है। वैज्ञानिकों ने आगाह करते हुए कहा है कि यद्यपि 1990 के बाद समुद्री तूफानों की कुल संख्या में कमी आई है लेकिन पूरी दुनिया में समुद्र सतह की तापमान वृद्धि इनकी तीव्रता में जबर्दस्त इजाफा कर रही है।        अमेरिका के जार्जिया इंस्टीट्यूट आफ टेक्नोलाजी और नेशनल सेंटर फार एटमोस्फियरिक रिसर्च ने संयुक्त रूप से 1970 से 2004 के बीच आए तूफानों की संख्या, अंतराल और तीव्रता पर विस्तृत अध्ययन किया। अध्ययन के निष्कर्ष जानीमानी विज्ञान पत्रिका साइंस के ताजा अंक में प्रकाशित हुए हैं। अध्ययन के मुखिया पीटर वेबस्टर ने बताया कि इस शोध के दौरान उन्हें हैरान कर देने वाले आंकड़े मिले। 1970 के दशक में जहां 4 और 5 श्रेणी वाले उच्च तीव्रता के तूफानों की  संख्या  पूरी दुनिया में औसतन 10 प्रतिवर्ष थी वहां 1990 के बाद इनकी संख्या दोगुनी हो गई। इतना ही नहीं तूफानों की कुल संख्या में उच्च तीव्रता के तूफानों का हिस्सा भी बढ़ गया। सत्तर के दशक में जहां कुल तूफानों में इनका हिस्सा 20 प्रतिशत था वहीं पिछले दशक में यह बढ़कर 35 प्रतिशत तक जा पहूंचा। तीव्र तूफानों की संख्या में वृद्धि उत्तरी प्रशांत, दक्षिण-पश्चिमी प्रशांत तथा उ त्तर   दक्षिण  हिन्दमहासागर में देखी गई है। शोधकर्ताओं ने बताया कि तूफानों की तीव्रता में बढ़ोत्तरी के पीछे समुद्र सतह की तापमान वृद्धि को जिम्मेदार ठहराया जा सकता है। वेबस्टर के अनुसार तूफानों की तीव्रता और समुद्र सतह के तापमान के बीच सीधा संबंध है। वे पृथ्वी के वातावरण निर्माण में तूफानों की भूमिका को जानने का भी प्रयास कर रहे हैं। बेवबस्टर मानते हैं कि तूफान समुद्री जल के वाष्पीकरण और फिर पुनर्वितरण के जरिए समुद्र के तापमान को कम करने का काम करते हैं।
हिन्दुस्तान टाइम्स (नई दिल्ली), 17 Sep.2005


 

Junk Petrol for Ethanol
 
Arun Firodia

An energy crunch looms large. Fossil fuel stocks are falling. Oil prices have broken the $70 barrier. Many countries are switching to biofuels. The EU has decided to use 5.75% biofuels like ethanol for motorcars by 2010. China plans to use 10% biofuels by 2010. The US already produces about 10 million tones of ethanol.             The US is adding 30% to its capacity while China is setting up the world’s biggest plant. Interestingly, Hentry Ford, the father of modern automobile, was an ardent advocate of ethanol as a fuel for motorcars. He was a great believer in recycling.                                                      
          We have started with a 5% ethanol blend with petrol, which can be increased to 10 & 20% progressively. Brazil is already successfully using 50% blend! With new technology it may be possible to use even 100% pure ethanol in car engines with some additives so that sensitive parts of the engine are not affected.      
         Ethanol is anhydrous, the purest form of alcohol. It is available as a byproduct in sugar factories. One tonne of sugarcane produces 100 kg of sugar (worth Rs 1,000) and 50 kg of ethanol (worth Rs 900). But the entire one tonne of sugarcane, if fed directly into a distillery, can produce 500 kg of ethanol (worth Rs 9,000). It, therefore, makes good commercial sense of produce ethanol as a main product in an independent distillery, rather than as a byproduct in sugar factory. Such distilleries can easily pay double the price of a sugar factory to a farmer.                   
        But sugarcane is an irrigated, water-intensive crop. What about a dryland farmer who depends on rainfed crops? Fortunately, new technology is available to produce ethanol from grain and stem juice of crops like sweet sorghum (meethijowar), barley and maize, which are starchy. A distillery can extract 380 liters of ethanol (worth Rs. 6,880) from one tonne of such crops. The distillery would be willing a pay double the prices to a dryland farmer compared to what he gets for his crops today. In this way, ethanol can usher in rural prosperity.      
       Our petrol consumption last year was eight million tones. We need only four lakh tones of ethanol to get a 5% blend. This can be easily produced from eight lakh tones of sugarcane, or just 0.3% of our total sugarcane production. This blend can also be produced from just 5% of total jowar and maize production (21 mmt) if fed directly to the distilleries. To cope with rising demand in future, we should turn to biotechnology to enhance crop yields. This is indeed possible, as demonstrated by a farmer in Maharashtra who has achieved sugarcane output of a record 355 tonnes/hectare through modern farming techniques, as against the present 60-70 tonnes/hectare.          The distillery can also produce lower grades of industrial or methyl alcohol (denatured spirit) and sell at Rs. 6-10 per liter. Industrial alcohol blended with kerosene (50% or even higher) can provide all the energy required in rural India. It can fire cooking stoves, light up lamps, drive water pumps, motorcycles or auto rickshaws and run cold storage units working on the absorption cycle. It will also save rural womenfolk the hardship of walking long distances to collect firewood and in the process save trees.                           
        The price of ethanol and industrial alcohol will fall substantially if the government exempts them from excise duty and sales tax. That would encourage their large-scale production and use. Oil companies could buy them from distilleries, blend them with petrol and kerosene and market such blends through roadside petrol and kerosene pumps. The kerosene pump is a novel idea whose time has come. Kerosene need not be subsidized or rationed any more. Just blend it (50% or more) with industrial alcohol and sell it freely.                    
      When crude oil was available at $20 per barrel, nobody bothered about biofuels. But now biofuels like ethanol are emerging as imperatives. To promote their use, the government must declare a comprehensive biofuel policy.  In doing so, it should correct certain tax anomalies. While  sugar  comes under central excise, alcohol  comes  under state excise. Rationalization of such rules, exemption from excise duty and sales tax, deregulation of feedstock and its pricing, simplification of licensing and other procedures will make our ethanol industry strong and vibrant. We could then benchmark ourselves with Brazil in production and pricing of ethanol. Brazil produces ethanol at half the price of US or Europe. Brazil has also developed techniques to treat the effluent called spent wash that is generated in a sugar factory or in a distillery. We need to learn and adopt these techniques or develop our own.     The day may not be far when the world starts importing ethanol from India, just as it imports crude oil from the Middle East.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 15 Sep. 2005


Environmentalists in Orissa feel they fight a losing battle as the state lines up projects likely to take further toll on the state’s ecology. As many as 37 MoUs have been signed to produce over 47 million tonne of steel per annum with an investment of Rs. 1,18,000 crore. Four alumina projects are coming up, besides six mega coalfired thermal plants.                    
          The state’s industrial history reveals a telling impact. The di-ammonia phosphate (DAP) plant of Oswal Chemicals and Fertilisers Ltd. near the port town of Paradip has turned out to be a pollution terror. Leakages of ammonia gas and sulphuric acid have turned vast farmland in Jagatsingpur district barren. Nalco’s ash pond disaster is still fresh in the memory of those living in Angul district. Its alumina refinery in Koraput is notorious for releasing toxins such as red mud, an alkali effluent, JK Papers in nearby Rayagada discharges one lakh tonne of lime sludge yearly. The Rourkela Steel Plant disposes vast amounts of basic slag, a waste emanating from smelting metal.                                                                    
         The worst polluters are the coal-fired thermal plants in the Angul and Jharsuguda districts. These include NTPC’s 3,000 mw thermal plant at Kaniha, Nalco’s 960 mw captive plant at Angul and the AES-managed Orissa Power Generation Corporation’s 420 mw station, belching a million tonne of fly ash into the air, turning the sky reddish white everynight. The sponge iron plants in Jharsuguda and Sundergarh district, however, paint the sky pitch dark, and their proliferation has become a major concern for the local people.                            
       The waters of four major rivers, Mahanadi, Brahmani, Baitarani and Nagabali, and their rivulets, stand polluted by industrial wastes, according to government records. The river Nandira faces premature death due to industrial effluents.                              
         Many of these industries are violating pollution norms with impunity. And the state’s pollution control board (OSPCB) has remained a silent spectator. Over the past 20 years, only 100 cases have been registered under the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, and 144 cases were filed under Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1986 by the OSPCB. Of the 244 cases, only 59 were diposed during the period.        
       “The pollution control board is not effective and therefore we demand the establishment of Special Green Courts in the state,” says   eminent  environmentalist Bibhudhendra   Pratap  Das.  He  adds  thatdespite several assurances from chief minister Naveen Patnaik, these courts are not coming up.  
        New projects don’t seem to be better. Vedanta Alumina, owned by Anil Agarwal’s London exchange-listed Vedanta Resources, is facing prosecution for destroying forests in Kalahandi district.     Another project facing environmentalists’ wrath is the Dhamra port project, promoted by the Singapore-based International Seaport Plc. Environmentalists are crying hoarse that the project will disturb the nesting ground of the Olive Ridley turtles, an endangered species that visits the coast to lay eggs every year.  
         “The environment will be the first casualty of industrialization,” says environmentalist Biswajit Mohanty. He suggests the government must pay adequate attention on this front, if it wants to avoid a disastrous outcome for the entire state in the coming years.
The Financial Express (New Delhi), 19 Sep. 2005


Militant trade unionism is mostly responsible for the lack of industrialization in Kerala. And, in the absence of large contiguous pieces of land in this densely populated state, setting up large industries is very difficult. Whatever little industrial progress that has taken place has come bundled with pollution-related issues, mostly raised by the state’s highly conscious citizens.                                               
          It is the policy of the state government not to go in for big industries, especially chemical-based ones, and it has chosen to concentrate on IT-related industry and tourism.                                   
          Way back in 1957, the first communist government gave the Birla-promoted Grasim Industries land at Re 1 per acre, subsidized power and softwood from the forests at nearly throw away prices. However, in 1999, the firm shut shop following a pubic outcry against it on the grounds that its factories were polluting the Chaliyar River, which led to the spread of cancer in the vicinity.           
         Recently, another movement has gathered steam against the Coca-Cola bottling plant at Plachimada in Palakkad district, which has remained closed for over a year. The people’s movement has been charging the company with indiscriminately drawing groundwater, leading to water scarcity in the vicinity. The state pollution control board’s (PCB) report, confirming toxic material in the slush flushed out by the company, gave strength to the movement. Finally, last week, the Kerala government filed a special leave petition before the Supreme Court, justifying the panchayat authority’s refusal to renew the company’s licence. It also challenged the Kerala High Court directive allowing the company to draw five lakh litres of ground water daily.               
         Kerala’s longest river, Periyar, has been polluted by industries in the Eloor belt in Kochi, forcing the PCB to step in. It was nearly a year ago that the Board issued closure notices to 189 industrial units in the state, which literally jolted the industry and the state. However, following a plea by the state government, it gave time to the companies to set up waste disposal facilities.                                         
         State PCB chairman G. Rajmohan told FE the Board was not against industrialization, as was being made to appear. On the contrary, it had been taking a    positive    stand   and   was   supporting industries to wake up and meet the pollution control norms.                                    
        The best example for this was the RPG group’s Philips Carbon Black factory near Kochi, which had to be closed after public opposition.                                   
      The PCB intervened and engaged consultants to ensure installation of necessary equipment to check pollution. Since then, the company had begun functioning smoothly, he added. The PCB also issued closure notice to Merchem Ltd, which manufactures rubber chemicals that go into tyre production, after it was found to be emitting noxious fumes, causing undue hardship to the local population. Though the company has installed the required facilities, these are yet to become functional. Mr. Rajmohan said the company would reach the zero-discharge level in a few weeks.                                    
       Advocate P.K. Ibrahim who heads the local area committee of the Supreme Court monitoring committee on hazardous waste said nothing was being done to hamper the state’s growth. It was through discussions with industrialists that it was striving to ensure a pollution-free climate in the state.
The Financial Express (New Delhi), 19 Sep. 2005


  Mathura Bans Polythene Bags

Uttar Pradesh government has decided to ban the use of polythene bags in the district as they were polluting the river Yamuna and posing a hurdle to the smooth running of the sewer system in the area. The ban has been imposed within the territory of municipal boards of Mathura and Vrindaban. No individual, firm, shop or group would be allowed to use any type of polythene bag, district magistrate Rajeev Rautela told reporters here on Thursday. The administration was left with no option but to impose a ban on its use as polythene waste is a major hurdle in smooth running of sewer system as it chokes them and also pollutes river Yamuna, he said. In this connection, executive officers of Mathura and Vrindaban have been instructed to make surprise raids on shops and factories, he said. This was being done in largest interest as awareness  rallies  and  raids  on polythene bag sellers  earlier  did  not  bear any fruitful result, he said.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 02 Sep. 2005


How Best to Beat Plastic Boom
 Bharati Chaturvedi

Let us not dispute the contention that Mumbai’s plastic bags choked the city during the floods. And that Mumbai’s response of banning them is sweet revenge. But will the ban provide a lasting solution to the problem?             Even at first glance, it is clear that politicians have missed the point. Eliminating plastic bags is a desirable objective. Even after seemingly radical policy moves, plastic bags never really get out of our system, only out of sight.    Global wisdom suggests that it’s important to look at the problem in multiple ways. If you want plastic bags out, you have to create multiple disincentives for their use.  
        Implementation woes         
                       
      A ban is unlikely to work, particularly in a large area, because it works on monitoring that Indian implementing agencies can never deliver. In smaller towns, like Ladakh and Nainital, the efficacy lies in a combination of civic participation and administrative measures. In Delhi, by contrast, plastic bags thrive as their alternatives fail to compete.                                               
      The industry’s hold                                               
     An issue that is currently not addressed in India is the responsibility of the plastics and polymer industry. A look at documents of the last two decades shows how this industry manipulated emerging policy on plastics. Task forces on addressing the plastic waste problem were dominated by the industry. All       other        voices – public     health, environment, industries that could provide the alternatives - were missing or silenced.     The only lasting solution to waste is to reduce it. Is it logical to expect the plastic industry to favour a policy that’s good for the country but bad for its balance sheets? It has subverted principals of ‘Extended Producer Responsibility’, where the producer of a product is deemed responsible for it throughout its life cycle. Instead, the industry blames the waste problem on consumers who do not dump the stuff into bins.  In Mumbai, the hub of India’s formal plastic recycling industry, the ban allows manufacturing of these bags, as long as they are sold someplace else.
    Answers, anyone?
                                    
    The Mumbai story offers us an opportunity to move ahead. First, the producer must be made liable to task back the waste for recycling, although only an inferior product will result. No take backs, no markets should be the attitude. Consumers must be offered a choice between plastic and its alternatives.   Second, plastics like PVC that are suspected to be toxic should be phased out within a timeframe.  Forth, the import of plastic waste, regardless of who it supports, should be stopped and the Customs trained to counter it. Fifth, incentives and support for alternative materials is essential, along with design that reduces plastics. Sixth, we need to establish state of art plastic down cycling plants for some types of non-toxic plastics.
Hindustan Times (New Delhi), 07 Sep. 2005


Use as many plastic bags as you want, recycled or otherwise. Even if you want to throw Kitchen waste, feel free to do so. There’s no one to catch you and impose heavy penalties. Delhi government has suddenly discovered that althrough it made use of biodegradable plastic mandatory in the Capital, it has forgotten to add penalty clauses in the amended Act. In March this year, the government had decided to take a novel green initiative. It had decided to nudge out non-biodegradable plastic bags and made it mandatory for one and all to use special degradable plastic bags that disintegrate completely and dissolve in the soil.            
        An amendment was made to the Delhi Plastic Bag (Manufacture, Sales and Usage) and Non-Biodegradable Garbage (Control) Act 2000 in December last year. This became effective in March.                    But the government over looked a teeny-weeny detail. As with all rules, it forgot the implementation part. The amendment did not include the penalties that could be imposed in case a person is caught using recyclable or normal non-biodegradable bags.                                      
         Delhi   environment   minister   Raj Kumar Chauhan said: “We are in the process of farming the rules.” The environment department is framing the penalties, which will be brought before the Delhi Cabinet and then would require the L-G’s approval before final implementation.                          
       When asked how the government overlooked penalties, Chauhan said: “There were problems. We thought that penalties of the earlier Act could be used in this. There were minor issues which are being sorted out.”         
       The government had decided to implement the amended Act in a phased manner. The first on the list were 100-bed hospitals and five-star hotels. But no inspections have been made to see if violations are taking place.        The amendment makes it mandatory for people to use and manufacture only biodegradable plastic bags. The Act says that any person found manufacturing or stacking up non-biodegradable plastic bags will be fined and punished.                                        
      Officials who cannot control the use of harmful plastic bags will also be penalised. But what the penalties will be is not known.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 16, Sep. 2005


The waste generated by hospitals and medical health institutions has become a major source of environment pollution here. Since there is no treatment plant in the district for the disposal of medical waste, the situation is alarming.  The infectious waste contains live pathogens and in the absence of any treatment plant, it has been noticed that the waste find its way to drains and municipal dumps.  Extensive use of plastic in health institutions is resulting in sharp increase in waste which needs special treatment plants. In fact, plastic has replaced glass in these institutions. Despite the fact that Kangra is the biggest district of the state where a large number of private and public health institutions are located, including the Government Medical College at Tanda, no efforts have been made in the past 10 years for scientific handling of biomedical waste. At present most of the waste is being thrown into ‘khuds’ and streams. Water from these streams is diverted to the public supply systems. Even the Irrigation and Public Health Department has no water treatment plant. People, therefore, have little choice but to take contaminated water. Official sources reveal that water borne diseases have become quite common here and every fifth person is suffering from the same.  In view of the indiscriminate disposal of bio-medical waste and increasing concern for health and environment, the Government of India has taken up on priority the task to regulate the waste generated by medical and health institutions. Amendments were also made in Environment and Forest Protection Act, 1986, in 1995-96, 1997-98, and 2001-02. Notifications to this effect were also circulated to the states. Subsequently in 1998, Biomedical Waste Management and Handling Rules-1998, 2001-02 were also forwarded to states by the Union Government for further action. These rules provide for a control on such waste.               
        But neither the Himachal Pradesh Government   nor  the  HP  State  Pollution Control Board  has  taken  these  important notifications and rules framed by the Government of India seriously. Therefore, various nursing homes and health institutions are openly flouting these rules not only in Kangra but in the entire state in the absence of any check by the government. The Municipal Council of Kangra is openly flouting these rules by dumping the entire medical waste near the town. Despite stiff opposition from the public and a various social organizations, the entire medical waste is being dumped in the stream and khuds which are the major source of drinking water. The district administration is aware of the prevailing situation but remains a silent spectator. Most of the municipal dumps situated on National Highways emit a foul smell all the time. Senior officers who pass by daily do not bother to initiate any action against the defaulters.                      
         Despite spending crores of rupees on protection and conservation of environment, the state has been facing serious environmental threats in different fields. Besides, various foreign-aided projects have also been launched in the state to check the environmental degradation in different districts, but nothing has been done sincerely in this field so far. The state is losing its vegetation cover rapidly. Illicit felling of trees and indiscriminate mining and quarrying is going on unchecked. Even protected forests have not been spared by the antisocial elements in the past 10 years. Experts have held our political set-up responsible for all these evils.
The Tribune (Chandigarh), 13 Sep. 2005


  Pollution Board Norms for Idol Immersion

The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) has asked the States to establish coordination committees during festival season to guide the public in immersing idols with minimal adverse impact on water bodies.             The committees can comprise members from the police, non-governmental organisations and representatives of religious groups. Issuing a set of guidelines for the state pollution control boards, the CPCB advised local bodies to notify and adequately publicise immersion centres every year at least a month before the festivals.                               
          It would be appropriate to use traditional clay rather than baked clay for making idols. Use of painted idols should be discouraged and in case, they are used, watersoluble and non-toxic natural dyes may be used, the Board said.                             
        It strictly prohibited the use of toxic and non-degradable chemical dyes. Natural colours used in food products and permitted in pharmaceuticals may be preferred.                                                        
        For immersion of idols in sea, it may be done beyond 500 metres of low-tide line, seeking help from proper motorboats with security personnel and home guards. In case of immersion in rivers and lakes, the CPCB recommends arrangements for construction of temporary bunds and disposal of material used for worship.         After immersion, river or pond water may be checked for colour and turbidity and adequately treated, if required.                                                            
       Prior to immersion, worship material such as flowers, vastras and decorating material should be removed and separately collected either for recycling or composting if biodegradable or for disposal, if non-biodegradable. Also, the leftover material at the immersion site should be collected by the local bodies within 24 hours after the function.                 
      The state pollution control boards should undertake water quality assessment preferably in Class-I cities (having population more than one lakh). Water quality monitoring should be conducted in three stages - pre-immersion, during immersion and post-immersion.              
       Considering the size of the water body, an appropriate number of sampling locations may be determined in order to get a fairly representative assessment of water quality like pH, bio-chemical oxygen demand, conductivity, turbidity, total dissolved solids and other heavy metals.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 13 Sep. 2005


  No Relaxation of Noise Pollution Norms

The Supreme Court on Friday rejected the plea of the Maharashtra Government for relaxation of the ban imposed by the former on use of loudspeakers between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. during the Ganesh Chaturthi festival next week.                                                                    
          A three-judge Bench, comprising Chief Justice R.C. Lahoti, Justice B.N. Srikrishna and Justice P.K. Balasubramanyan, during ‘mention time’ on the petition filed by the State Environment Secretary told counsel, “Let Ganesh Chaturthi be celebrated peacefully this year.”                                           
         When counsel told the Bench that Maharashtra had framed rules and regulations and that it should be permitted to implement them, the Bench said: “We have passed the judgement. You do whatever you want. You can’t seek review of the judgment in this petition”.               
          The State Government said it was constrained to file this petition since people in Maharashtra had been following their religions customs, festivals and traditions with all its facets for centuries.     
         It said the situation in Mumbai was also very unique. Most of the festivals had their origin in their authentic text such as singing of aartis during Ganpathi festival accompanied by music on loudspeakers.          
         In the mosques there used to be morning azans over the loudspeakers.   The   petition  stated  that  the  total ban on use of loudspeakers between 10 p.m. and 6 p.m. would disturb the sentiments of the public and could even bring police confrontation with the public.     
      This would have serious implications for various festival seasons where NGOs would demand implementation of the apex court directive whereas at the ground level real implementation would not be easy.           It wanted relaxation of the norms for 15 days in a year, five days for Ganesh Chaturthi, two days during Navarathri, one day each on Diwali, Id-e-Milad, Shiv Jayanthi, Dr. Ambedkar jayanthi, Christmas and remaining three days permission to be given by authorities in consultation with the District Collector on local religious festivals.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 03 Sep. 2005


For the Union Government cleaning the dying Yamuna will not be an easy task, particularly in the wake of the Supreme Court’s recent direction to accomplish the task through an action plan drawn up on the lines of the British Government’s success in cleaning up the river Thames in London.                                 
         While it took the British Government almost two decades to clean up and revive the once “biologically dead” Thames, the Indian Government’s has presented to the Apex Court just a four-year project to clean up the Yamuna. The Centre’s plan is to set up sewage treatment plants (STPs) at points where all major drains meet the river Yamuna to ensure that no untreated sewage or industrial effluent get discharged into the river.                      
          Interestingly, the condition of the Yamuna today is almost the same as that of the Thames in 1950’s, and in 1957, London’s Natural History Museum declared the Thames “biologically dead”. It was after this that the cleaning and rehabilitation work in the river commenced with the British Government improving sewage waste treatment and banning industry from discharging pollutants into the river.                   
        According to the National Geographic news.com, now the river that flows through the heart of Europe’s largest city is awash with life. “More than 130 seals have been spotted in the Thames since last August, according to the Zoological Society of London. Bottlenose dolphins have been seen upstream of London Bridge. With 120 fish species, hundreds of thousands of birds, and a thriving fishing industry, the river now ranks among the cleanest metropolitan tideways in the world.”                
      Quoting Martin Attrill, a marine biologist at the University of Plymouth, England, the website states that the condition of the Thames was very different 150 years ago. 1858 saw the “Great Stink” when the stench of raw sewage got so bad that Parliament, which meets in a river-side building, had to be dissolved.         
       “In 1878, the pleasure steam-ship Princess Alice sunk in a river collision. Most of the 600 or so passengers who died did so because they were overpowered by a noxious cocktail of human and industrial filth before they could reach safety. By the 1950s the Thames was in an even worse state. A 20-km stretch of river was completely devoid of oxygen.”    
      The website further adds that today more than half of London’s sewage sludge is sold in pellet form as fertilizer for agricultural use. Mr. Attrill says water quality has continued to improve since the 1970s. There’s been a clear and very dramatic decrease in levels of heavy metals and pesticides.                             
      However, the story of the Yamuna has been grim as the Comptroller and Auditor General’s latest report states that the Delhi Government’s plan for controlling water pollution in the river has been termed as a “big flop” as the Rs. 872 crores spent on this project has gone down the drain.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 13 Sep.2005


Traditional Knowledge a Legal and Market Conundrum
 
Prodipto Ghosh

Protecting biological or genetic diversity is an investment into the future of any society. Genetic diversity is useful for development of new products and processes: crops, pharmas, etc. Genetic information is contained in a seed and it is what is required for tracing the genome of a species. Significant quantities of biological material are not required. A ‘few seeds’ from a location can give all the information about the genome, thus making bio-piracy very simple.                 
          All information which is non-rival in use and all non-depletable resources constitute biological diversity and the accompanying traditional knowledge (TK). For the ‘owner’ of these to derive benefit, TK has to be made legally excludable in use. Putting a value to TK is difficult. Locating a biological resource with potential for a certain useful property is the proverbial ‘needle in the haystack’ problem. TK, relying on empirical knowledge gleaned by traditional societies, enables the search (and associated costs) in modern medicine to be reduced manifold. TK is non-rival in use, but for the holder to derive value, needs to be excludable in use. Thus, the value of TK is a derived value, rather than an intrinsic one.                                   
         There was a paradigm shift in the protection of TK through the Biodiversity Convention (CBD), 1992. Prior to CBD, genetic resources (and TK) were essentially global public property. CBD recognized that states have sovereign rights over their biological resources and TK and it provided a framework for access and benefit sharing for genetic resources and TK.                                        
       However, CBD had many deficiencies. First, there was no legal provision for ensuring excludability of genetic resources and TK, which implied that ‘biopiracy’ could continue without penalty. Second, there was a mandatory, but not enforceable ‘barter’ of access to biological resources for ‘transfer’ of technology. Third, there was no provision for access benefits to be paid in money. Fourth, ‘transfer’ of technology was not defined. Thus, bio-piracy has increased. The use office of patents granted 17,239 patents on 119 medicinal plants in 2000; the number rose to 20,835 in 2002 and 23,956 in 2004-05.                                  
        This increase in bio-piracy points to the need for a multilateral access and benefits sharing (ABS) regime, with some basic characteristics. One, both genetic resources and TK to be made excludable in use. Two, grant of IPRs involving these resources must be made contingent on a letter of Prior Informed Consent (PIC) from holders of the resources. Three, IPRs must be cancelled if issued without disclosure of such use of wrongful disclosure. Four, it must provide for a range of benefits to be mutually negotiated, rather than barter as in CBD.      
       Implementation of such regimes will require coordinated changes in CBD and TRIPS regimes. It will also require efficient domestic legal regimes.                   
       It is worth noting that India’s Patent Act now requires the mandatory disclosure of origin (genetic resources) and prior art (TK). Non-disclosure or wrongful disclosure would lead to cancellation the patent. A further step is, however, required. This would include insistence on a letter of PIC from the holders of genetic resources/TK, endorsed by the National Biodiversity Authority.      
    Apart from the legal framework which needs to be rectified, there are a number of other market failures associated with the use of genetic diversity/TK which results in the holders getting poor returns. First comes the asymmetric information between users and holders. The user is better informed about the potential value of TK than the holder. The latter cannot rely on past contracts, as resources and their uses are highly diverse. The historical story of “selling Manhattan for a bag of beads” is worth recalling.                 
     However, even the user’s information improves with the progress of R&D. Both, seller and user will be risk-averse if a complete contract is to be entered into at the beginning. The problems of a potential monopoly (holder)/monophony (user) bargaining situation may also result in no contact being issued, to the detriment of both. Even more complex arrangements, like a three-agent bargaining problem, where the TK holder, the holder of the genetic resource and the user are involved, may result in a situation of gain for all. Thus, while the legal framework is important, a realistic assessment of the market and its drivers are also required to ensure benefits accrue evenly from granting access rights to genetic resources/TK.
The Financial Express (New Delhi), 07 Sep. 2005


Over the past decade, traditional knowledge (TK) has received increasing attention on the international agenda. Factors contributing to this include the recognition of TK’s importance in the lives of the majority of the world’s population and in the conservation of biodiversity; concerns about the rapid loss of TK and global cultural diversity; concerns about unauthorized and inappropriate patenting and use of TK, with little or no sharing of resulting benefits with the original holders of TK; interest in harnessing the potential of TK for local sustainable development; and increasing attention to indigenous rights.   Many countries and communities worldwide are considering how to best address this issue at the national, regional and international levels. TK is a complex and multifaceted issue. Therefore a holistic and multi-dimensional approach is needed, comprising simultaneous actions at national and international levels.
          It is important to start with identification of objectives and then to identify possible tools that could help meet these objectives. Recent Unctad work has identified three broad categories of objectives, namely, preservation, protection, and promoting TK for development (‘the three Ps’) and identified menus of possible actions and measures that could be taken, particularly at the national or regional level, to meet these objectives.            At the national level, each country can choose the measures to take based on national priority objectives identified. Multi-stakeholder consultations are needed to raise awareness of the issues, identify underlying needs and concerns of different societal sectors, including indigenous groups, and ensure public engagement in and support of the plan eventually developed.                      
           To preserve TK, a number of actions can support the ex situ preservation of TK, notably TK registries and museums, as well as, more importantly, the in situ preservation of TK as a dynamic, constantly evolving body of knowledge in living diverse communities. National actions aimed at the latter include media transmissions in local languages, including TK in formal education, training youth, preservation of the natural environment, secure land rights and enhancing livelihoods.                           
       Protection aims to prevent the unauthorized or inappropriate use of TK by third parties. This includes unauthorized commercial use as well as applications for intellectual property rights (IPRs) that are based on TK, but made without the prior informed consent (PIC) of the TK-holders and without benefit sharing. Possible national-level actions include disclosure of source of origin of genetic resources and related TK in IPR applications, recognition of the ownership of TK-holding communities of their TK, recognition of customary law and use of conventional IP instruments, such as geographical indications.         
         TK plays a key role in development, as it is the main resource of the poor. To promote TK for development, sharing experiences among communities, as well as countries, helps keep this body of knowledge growing. Supporting the development of local and indigenous community-run ventures aimed at sustainable livelihoods requires actions that are similar to supporting any small enterprises, including capacity building in entrepreneurial skills, access to finance and markets and facilitating partnerships with larger enterprises.          India’s Honey Bee Network offers useful experience in means of promoting and scaling up TK-based innovations. Value addition by, and benefit sharing with, TK holders are important considerations. The international community can support developing country efforts to harness TK for development through technical cooperation and facilitating market access and entry for TK-based products, such as non-wood forest products, ethnic foods, traditional medicinal products and handicrafts. At the international level, much of the attention has been focused on TK protection. Many feel that there is a lack of balance in the current IPR system as enshrined in the TRIPS agreement and various WIPO treaties. One type of IP-that generally produced and owned by entities in developed countries – is well protected. That category of IP in which developing countries have comparative advantage, namely TK, is generally considered free for all takers.  
          To redress this imbalance, a number of actions have been proposed by developing countries, with India often at the forefront. A key proposal is to amend the WTO TRIPS Agreement to require disclosure of origin/source of genetic resources and associated TK in relevant patent applications. This would help; countries keep track of how their genetic resources are being used and patented abroad. Ideally, such a requirement would also include evidence of PIC and benefit sharing.                         
          India has also been a main proponent of another defensive IP measure, namely, making TK that is clearly in the public domain more accessible to patent examiners around the world, so as to prevent IPRs on this TK being in appropriately granted to third parties. These two measures could go a long way in preventing ‘bad patents.’ However, to prevent unauthorized or misappropriate commercial use (without IPRs) would require a farther-reaching positive system of protection. This may involve an international sui generis system that recognizes national systems related to TK protection, PIC and ABS. CBD negotiations   on   international   treaty   on ABS have  begun.  Much  will  depend  on how those negotiations proceed and what weight the results will carry. Effective treaties need teeth.

The Financial Express (New Delhi), 07 Sep. 2005


The Phancha panchayat area in the remote Pandrah-Beesh area of Shimla district is a classic example of what need-based micro planning can help achieve in improving the socio-economic conditions of the people.              Coordinated efforts made under the forestry reform project have brought a sea change in five wards of Phancha Nati Tikar, Phancha, Kandri, Pachagar, Magara and Ghanvi.                                    
            Located at 42 km from Jeori, the panchayat abound in forest wealth. The main occupation of the people is agriculture and sheep rearing. The panchayat has no road connectivity and people have to walk two to three hours on foot to reach the nearest road head at Ghanvi.                                          
             The Rs. 60 crore forest reform project, started in 2003 in 85 pilot locations in backward and remote areas of the state where people are mostly dependent on forests for their livelihood, has changed the life of the local people.    The project is being implemented in the five wards through 25 consumer groups. The main  stress  is  being  laid  on micro-planning at the grassroot level with the active participation and involvement of the people. The construction of pedestrian paths, worms compost pits development, water tanks, rainwater tanks, harvesting structures, training and financial help are the main components of the project.                
        Two storage tanks constructed under the project have brought more area of the panchayat under irrigation. Earlier, the farmers were dependent on the rains and only traditional crops like “fafra”, “koda” and potato were grown. Now cultivation of off-season vegetables is being adopted by the farming community.   
      The women folk have been imparted training in handloom and weaving and people are adopting latest techniques in sheep rearing. Financial help is being provided to set up handloom.     
       The Forest Department organises regular awareness camps in the panchayat to educate people about the scientific conservation of the precious forest wealth. A special afforestation campaign has been launched in the panchayat with people’s participation to cover the barren land.
The Tribune (Chandigarh), 13 Sep. 2005


  World Bank Nod to Forestry Project Soon

The World Bank is likely to give its final nod to the Rs. 370 crore Mid-hill Himalayan Watershed Development Project, the biggest scheme in the forestry sector, by October 1.                                 
             A team of the bank will arrive here on September 18 for the final appraisal mission after which the project will be cleared. The government had submitted a Rs. 540 crore proposal which was pruned during evaluation by the experts of the bank. To be implemented over a period of seven years. The project will cover the ecologically fragile mid-hill areas on an altitude of 1800 feet to 5000 feet. In all about 400 panchayats of 10 districts, excluding those already included in the Kandi project or D.I.F.I.D. project will be covered. Only the tribal district of Kinnaur and Lahaul – Spiti will remain uncovered. The focus of the project will be on conservation of water, which is increasingly becoming scarce. Besides vegetative measures, check dams and water harvesting structures and other civic works will also  be  constructed  under  the project. The water impounded through  the measures will be used for irrigation to enable the farmers in the rainfed areas to diversify into cash crops.                                  
        The integrated project will be implemented through people’s participation adopting the watershed approach. Micro planning will be carried out at the Panchayat level for each watershed keeping in view the requirement of the local people and available resources.          
       Along with afforestation and water conservation measures, the project will aim at improving farm productivity through dissemination of latest know-how, besides high-yielding seeds and milch cattle.
The Tribune (Chandigarh), 15 Sep. 2005


  More Rights to States in Forest Conservation Sought

The Rajasthan Forest, Environment and Mines Minister, Laxminarain Dave, has called for according more rights to states in the management and conservation of forests by decentralization of powers in the norms implemented by the Centre.            
         Mr. Dave also sought special status for Rajasthan in view of its difficult geography.                    
       Addressing a public function in Udaipur on Saturday, Mr. Dave said Rajasthan needed a special package from the Centre to facilitate 20 to 30% expansion in the forest area on the lines of the north-eastern States, while the task of environment protection in the desert state also required a special status.            
      Appeal for afforestation
                             
      Mr. Dave, while appealing to the people at large to contribute actively to the afforestation drive, said devolving of more powers on the state in the field would help in faster expansion and better management of forest reserves.                                                
     The Minister, referring to the huge oil finds in western parts of the state, said the state government was trying to get an oil refinery established in the region.              
    This, he pointed out, would lead to an investment of Rs. 6,000 crores to Rs. 8,000 crores in the state, providing employment directly to 20,000 persons and indirectly to nearly 1lakh people.    Mr. Dave said the mining policy to be implemented shortly in the state would lay emphasis on simplification of procedures and launching of employment-oriented scheme, besides augmenting revenue generation.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 06 Sep. 2005


  Green Doon May Soon Become a Memory
 
Jaskiran Chopra

The brunt of Doon’s so-called growth and development is being borne by its stately trees, its grasslands and scrubs and its riverine eco-system.  As the city rushes into the fast track lane, it is tearing into the very fabric of this green and quiet town. For the past few decades, Dehradun has been expanding exponentially, encroaching into the surrounding agricultural lands and forests and spilling into its riverine system. Things have become worse ever since the town became the interim capital of Uttaranchal five years ago. Construction is on at a frenzied pace in the once serence valley as the burgeoning city expands to accommodate the massive influx of urban population.                                                   
       At risk are the valley’s majestic Amaltas, Jamun, Silver Oaks and other trees that are being recklessly hacked and uprooted to make way for wider roads, swanky showrooms and hotels. And there is more destruction in store if the citizens do not wake up immediately to this loss.  A walk on the famous
Rajpur Road will show just how many of the remaining stately trees are marked for the axe man. The red X marks spell doom for the valley’s trees which have always given it a unique identity. Says Lokesh Ohri, convenor of Indian National Trust For Art and Cultural Heritage (INTACH), Dehradun, and a conservationist, “Doon is treating   its  trees as  encroachers,  turning them out and culling them at will.   “All over the world, cities harbour a variety of water bodies, parks and gardens and forests. Some cities have old monuments and wonderful old trees as their wealth,” he told TOI.                              
      “The Doon valley was so synonymous with greenery that it used to be said that even walking sticks sprout roots and shoots during the monsoon,” he said. Over 650 species of birds can be spotted during the year in the valley, which was often called “the town of grey heads and green hedges.”                                
      But now, said Ohri, the town was becoming a tourist destination without an identity. “What becomes of a town that has an East Canal Road sans a canal? What becomes of a town that has Eucalyptus Road (these trees were not your run-of-the mill commercial Eucalyptus but one of the finest, most stately species brought in from Australia which provided the genetic material that heralded India’s urban forestry resurgence under Sanjay Gandhi), without a tree in sight?” he asked.                      
      Infrastructural development is devouring the green cover of the town, reducing it into a faceless concrete jungle. “Why would people from the concrete jungles come here then?”            
       And this race for progress, it seems the Monitoring Committee to ensure greenery in Doon, which was set up 14 years ago at Supreme Court’s directive, has been given a quiet burial.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 18 Sep. 2005


  Sweet Stevia Hot Among Herbal Farmers
 Amit Bhattacharya

It is nature’s sweetest produce; a shrub whose leaves are 15 to 20 times candied than sugarcane. And unlike sugar, it is a zero-calorie food. This is ‘wonder herb’ Stevia rebaudiana, once found only in the highlands of Paraguay and now the hottest plant among herbal farmers in India.                 
           Stevia is free of carbohydrates and fat. It does not affect blood sugar levels when consumed, making it deal for diabetics as well as the calorie-conscious. And, it doesn’t leave a bitter after-taste like most artificial sweeteners. The shrub, that grows to about two feet in height, was traditionally used by Guarani Indians of South America for sweetening food and as a medicinal herb. It was first documented by the western world at the turn of the 20th century.                                                    
           In a country with highest number of diabetics in the world - estimated to touch 10 crore by 2010 - stevia is set on a steady growth path in India. Conservative figures put the stevia market at over Rs 1,000 crore in next five years.    Seizing on the prospects, farmer bodies and plant research companies have now developed Indian strains of the shrub. Says Rajaram Tripathi, president of Central Herbal Agro Marketing Federation of India (CHAMF), an organic farmers’ cooperative boasting of over 1,500 members, “We have developed two new varieties of stevia - MDS-13 and MDS - 14. These strains can tolerate temperatures between 4 and 50 degree Celsius, so stevia can be grown in most parts of the country.” There are reports of other indigenous strains being developed. For instance, Pune based Sun Fruits has come out with three new strains and plant tissue culture company Growmore Bio-tech has also developed stevia varieties.          CHAMF plans to have 500 acres under stevia cultivation by December this year and raise this to 10,000 acres within a couple of years. It is also negotiating to export the herb.                                  
     “Stevia has emerged as the most sought after crop for herbal farmers,” says Tripathi.  Not without reason. For, the returns are just as sweet. “Stevia gives growers 10 to 15 times more returns than conventional crops,” says Tushar Ajgaonkar, brand manager, Naturell, Mumbai-based Company that manufactured Stugar, a sweeterner extracted from stevia.                                       
     Such is the potential demand among farmers that in July this year. ICICI Lombard General Insurance introduced a weather insurance cover for stevia crop in Punjab.                             
        Stevia is available in the market as leaf, paste, powder or herbal tea. Watchers say stevia will really take off if the government grants permission for its extract to be marketed as a ready-to-consume bio-sweetener.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 13 Sep. 2005


  Campaign Launched for Biological Control of a Dangerous Weed
 Gargi Parsai

The National Research Centre for Weed Science, an institute of the Indian Council of Agriculture Research, has launched a campaign for biological control of the Mexican parthenium weed through beetles imported from Mexico. The weed is popularly known as Congress grass. It is also called carrot weed because it resembles a carrot plant and it now found in all parts of the country.                 
          Parthenium hysterophorus is a weed that was imported into India along with the PL 480 Mexican wheat seeds in the 50s. The weed has since grown into uncontrollable proportions invading millions of hectares of uncultivated wastelands, roadsides, railway tracks, etc. The fast growing weed is a nuisance in public parks, residential colonies and orchards.                                                       
        Not only that, it causes health hazards such as skin allergy, hay fever and asthma in human beings and is toxic to livestock. It squeezes grasslands and pastures, reducing the fodder supply. Scientists describe it as a “poisonous, allergic and aggressive weed posing a serious threat to human beings and livestock.”           
        The presence of parthenium in cropped lands results in yield reduction up to 40%. The pollen grains inhibit fruit set in tomato, brinjal, beans, etc. it is also responsible for bitter milk disease in livestock fed on grass mixed with parthenium.                                        
       Parthenium is a fast maturing plant with a deep tap root that can grow to a height of 1.5 to 2 metres having branched leaves covered with fine hairs. It grows a large number of small white flowers and seeds of light weight that are easily dispersed to distant places causing allergy in human beings. Each  plant  can  produce up to 10,000 seeds. It has the capacity to re-grow from the cut or broken parts. It has no natural enemies such as insects and diseases because of which it spreads rapidly in India.                                    
        According to N.T. Yaduraja, Director of the Jabalpur-based Centre, one of the ways to control the weed is to uproot the weed before flowering. Any newly emerging seedlings should be removed. Herbicides such as glyphosate (one to 1.5%) for total vegetation control or metribuzin (0.3 to 0.5%) could be used if the grasses are to be saved.               
       Another said an effective way of controlling the weed is to spread seeds of self-perpetuating competitive plant species such as cassia sericea, cassia tora, tagetus erecta and tephrosia purpurea.       
        After much research, Mexican beetles (zygogramma bicolorata) was considered a “safe” bio-control agent. The institute is now campaigning for using this beetle for parthenium suppression.       
        The larvae feed for 10 to 15 on the leaves and on maturity enters the soil and pupates below up to 15cm depth. The beetles emerge after eight to 12 days and completes its life-cycle in 27 to 32 days. Both the adults and larvae are capable of feeding on the parthenium leaves thus checking the plant growth and flower production.         Adults defoliate the plant. Immature flowers are cut by the beetles in an effort to chew the soft tissues beneath the flowers. Completely defoliated plants start to show dieback symptoms and gradually get killed.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 04 Sep. 2005


 

Sibal Wants Crab in Endangered List
 Kounteya Sinha

Scientists at the National Institute of Oceanography have found that a compound derived from the blood of a horseshoe crab acts as a diagnostic reagent for bacteria, which causes diseases like typhoid and meningitis. They have also found that the shell of the crab can be used to create wound dressings for use on burn victims and skin-graft donors. The compound accelerates healing by 35-50% and helps reduce pain.                                   
          Now alarmed at the fast pace of its extinction and stunned at the animals medicinal properties, the ministry of science and technology is planning to ask environment and forest minister A. Raja to declare the crab – which also has potential to treat diabetes and cancer – an endangered species.               
         While Japan has already declared it a protected animal, India wants to include the animal in Schedule IV of the Wildlife act. Science and technology minister Kapil Sibal said “We will write to the environment ministry for such an initiative which would allow it to be used for research purposes.”                         
         The bizarre-looking horseshoe crab is a living fossil. It pre-dates the dinosaurs and it hasn’t changed for 250 million years. It’s not really a crab and is more closely related to a tick.                  
         At present, there are five different species of the animal found in US, India, Malaysia, Japan and China. “The blood of the Horseshoe Crab has a critical component, known as T.A.L which clots when exposed to bacteria.                            
        All drugs intended for human use can be tested with the compound. Some medical equipment and devices, such as IV tubing, can also be tested with T.A.L.       
       The shell of the crab has also medical benefits. Chitin filaments can be used to create suture material and wound dressings for use on burn victims and skin-graft donors. We have already received eight patents relating to horse shoe crab inventions,”                                     
        N.I.O. scientist Dr. K. Anil Chatterjee said. N.I.O. meanwhile has also developed a process by which blood is drawn from the base of the animal’s leg to extract T.A.L. In other countries, the animal is killed to extract the compound.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 06 Sep. 2005


 Mahseer Facing Extinction
 Ravinder Sood

The golden mahseer (Tor putitora), which was categorized as an endangered species by the National Bureau of Fish Genetic Resources, Lucknow, in 1992, has been facing extinction in Himachal Pradesh. Its population is declining due to various reasons, including construction of dams, barrages and habitat shrinkage. While over cultivation and poaching deplete its numbers, the construction of barrages acts as physical barriers during its migration. Due to the construction of dams most of the mahseer has become local population.           Meanwhile, members of the Himachal Angling Association are worried over the dilly-dally attitude of the government in the construction of a mahseer seed farm. For the farm, the Central Government had provided a financial assistance.                                   
          Despite investing substantial money in various researches, the Fishery Department has failed to develop a technology for controlled breeding of golden mahseer. The association has submitted a Rs. 2.75-crore project on mahseer preservation and promotion of angling to the state government.   
         Mr. K.B. Ralhan, secretary general of the association, suggests measures for its conservation. These are releasing more water from dams, educating the public on better management of fishery resources, improving watch and ward services and stocking fingerlings through scientific methods.
The Tribune, (Chandigarh), 17 Sep. 2005


Chilka Dolphins in Peril
 Prafulla Das

After the death of 38 Irrawaddy dolphins in Chilka lake in the past three years, the Orissa Government has decided to move. A meeting called by Orissa Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik on Tuesday, decided to declare the brackish water lagoon’s outer channel zone near Satapada a dolphin sanctuary, impose restrictions on plying of motorised boats for dolphin watching and using of various types of fishing nets.             
          The sanctuary would be spread over 34.03 sq. km. More than 70% of the 111dolphins in the lake are in the area earmarked for the sanctuary. It is here that a majority of them fall victim to the propellers of boats and are caught in nets. The high mortality rate has been worrying the State Government and conservationists have been demanding action to check the boats. According to data, 15, 11 and 12 deaths were reported in 2003, 2004 and 2005 respectively. This number far exceeds natural mortality rates.                 
          About 500 mechanised boats are operated and more carcasses are found from October to February – the peak season. Nets such as the Almi and the Khonda prove fatal. Out of 12 deaths reported this year four were due to nets.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 15 Sep. 2005


India has tightened its surveillance against avian influenza, which has hit poultry and ducks in several countries in Asia. States have been asked to be particularly alert against infection from migratory birds arriving at sanctuaries.          
         Responding to a Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) warning issued on Wednesday, Animal Husbandry Secretary P.M.A Hakim said, “India is free of avian influenza. But we have strengthened surveillance and asked State Governments to do frequent sample surveys. They have been asked to report any untoward deaths of poultry or ducks. But there is nothing to worry.”    
          The FAO has issued a warning for countries that fall along migratory routes of wild birds to be on alert against the strain of avian flu carried over long distance. “The deadly strain of avian influenza that has hit several countries in Asia is likely to be carried over long distances along the flyways of wild water birds to the Middle East, Europe, South Asia and Africa,” the FAO said. India and Bangladesh, which are currently uninfected, are also considered to be at risk. Bangladesh – and to a lesser extent India – has large numbers of domestic ducks. Both countries are situated along one of the major migratory routes, and have the potential to become new large endemic areas, the FAO has warned. Birds flying from Siberia, where the H5NI virus has been detected, may carry the virus to the Caspian and Black Sea in the foreseeable future. These regions in the Balkans could become a potential gateway to Central Europe for the virus. Bird migration routes also run across Azerbaijan, Iran, Iraq, Georgia, Ukraine and some Mediterranean countries, where bird flu out breaks are possible, the FAO said.     
            “Avian influenza is an international problem that definitely needs a strong international response,” to said FAO’s Chief Veterinary Officer Joseph Domenech.                                   
             Bird flu has killed more than 60 persons in Asia since 2003 and more than 140 million birds have died or have been slaughtered in the efforts to contain prevent outbreaks. Health experts have warned that bird flu has the potential to trigger a global human pandemic if the virus adapts and becomes easily transmitted transmittable between humans.  Close contacts between humans, domestic poultry and wildlife should be reduced and closely monitored. On farms and markets, domestic birds should be strictly separated from wild animals to the greatest extent possible. Vaccinating poultry could also be considered in at risk situations.                                
              India has survived the outbreak due to strict vigilance at the borders and on farm.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 02 Sep. 2005


  House Sparrow on Verge of Extinction
 Vishal Gulati

Cities of Punjab and Haryana are no longer a habitat of a house sparrow. It’s chirping is fading from the vicinity of human habitation.                                             
           A small plump brownish bird, which is a widely distributed species in most parts of Europe and Asia, it is slowly disappearing from urban areas. Flocks of the sparrow, which were a common sight till a few years ago, are now rarely seen.    Ornithologists attribute a number of reasons to this phenomenon. These include lack of nesting sites, use of pesticides and non-availability of food. Even in the UK the bird has undergone a drastic decline.                          
         Lieut-Gen Baljit Singh (retd), a Chandigarh-based bird watcher, says since the sparrow is closely associated with man, it is the man who is responsible for its decline. He observe that the decline is due to lack of holes for nesting in modern houses and cutting of hedges from gardens.       
          Earlier houses had a number of crevices and holes. This enabled the bird to make nests. These days’ houses have little space for making nests. Use of heavy doses of pesticides in kitchen gardens and fields results in the decline of invertebrate fauna. Small insects play a very important role in the survival of newborn sparrows. It is believed that with the decline in insect numbers the survival rate of the newborns has come down.             
         Mr. Suresh C. Sharma, a member of the Delhi Bird Club, blames the use of chemically treated seeds by farmers for its decline. A sparrow feeds mainly on seeds.     Similarly, the treated grains available in the market are also a slow poison for the bird.                                        
         He   says   it   is   almost  extinct  in Bangalore. In Himachal Pradesh and the rural areas of Haryana, a good number of sparrows can be spotted.            
         “We lace their food with liberal doses of pesticides,” says Mr. S.K. Sharma, president, Environment Society of India, Chandigarh. The pesticides are used for preserving the grains.                  
          Reduced spillage of grains, improved storage, decline in the practice of feeding sparrows, increased predation by owls and cats and competition for food by other species, including pigeons, are threatening the existence of sparrows.
The Tribune (Chandigarh), 20 Sep. 2005


  Vulture Breeding Center Runs into Trouble
 
Ruchika M. Khanna

The vulture-breeding programme at the Vulture Conservation Breeding Centre at Pinjore has run into trouble with wildlife officials of Haryana.                            
          The wildlife officials in the state say though the center was set up for breeding of the highly endangered white-back, long-billed and Himalayan Griffon vultures (Schedule I birds), but in the past over three years no breeding of birds has taken place at the center. The center is run jointly by the Bombay Natural History Society (BNHS) and the Forest Department, Haryana.         
          Interestingly, while the wildlife wing of the Forest Department is gunning for the center, Forest Department officials have come in support of the Centre, claiming that there were no discrepancies in its flagship project - the vulture-breeding programme at Pinjore.                 
          In a report submitted to the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, the wildlife officials have said that the scientists at the center cannot even identify the sexes of the birds.      
         “The Principal Scientist of the B.N.H.S at the center, Dr. Vibhu Prakash, has conceded that they are not even sure if breeding in the coming years will take place or not,” reads the report.               
          “As per the report submitted by Dr. Vibhu Prakash, there has been no breeding of vultures at the center so far, during the past three and half years since April, 2002. According to the scientist, vultures breed only when they are four to five years’ old. Though there are sufficient number of such vultures at the center, during the past three to four years, yet no breeding has taken place till date”… says the report submitted to the ministry. It also says that five of the 51 captured birds died at the center from January to June this year, because of rock bee sting attack.               
          It was in the instructions of the Government of India that a quarterly report was sought from the center officials by the Chief Wildlife Warden, Haryana. Information was sought regarding area of capture, date of capture, sex of captured birds and their health. The center has been allowed to capture 150 Gyps species of vultures, on the condition that they submit a quarterly report to the ministry through the Chief Wildlife Warden.           The report submitted by the center on August 29, said that identification marks had been put on all 51 captured birds, aviaries are maintained properly, vultures are normal and are fed on freshly slaughtered goats. The report also admits that there is no breeding of vultures, though a few white backed vultures have shown signs of pair formations.                
          In spite of repeated attempts to contact the Director of the B.N.H.S, Dr. Asad Rehamani at Mumbai and  Dr. Vibhu Prakash, over the past two days, they were not available. However, senior forest officials say that breeding generally takes a long time. “The vultures died at the center of bee attack, and not for any negligence. With regards to the charges levelled against the center for being unable to identify the sexes, sexing is an evolving technique in India. The center for Cellular and Molecular Biology, Hyderabad, which is evolving this technique, has been contacted for the job. We are also trying to get in touch with some foreign agencies, which have patented sexing of birds, to identify the sexes,” says a senior forest department officer.
The Tribune (Chandigarh), 15 Sep. 2005


  Farm Chirus, Save Shahtoosh
 
Swaminathan S. Anklesaria Aiyar

The shahtoosh shawl is the most prized of all, beloved of Mughal emperors. It is very warm, yet so soft and fine that it passes through a ring. But buying a shahtoosh shawl today is illegal, and the industry is dying.              Why? Because the animal that yields shahtoosh, the chiru of Tibetan antelope, is becoming extinct through relentless hunting.                            
           Shahtoosh should not be confused with pashmina, the fine fleece of the pashmina goat. Pashmina can be combed out of the coat of the live animal. But shahtoosh comes from the undercoat of the chiru, lying beneath the outer coat, and cannot be harvested without shinning (and hence killing) the animal.                    
          Once, traders spread the myth that the chiru rubbed its neck against rocks, shahtoosh fell off, and was gathered by hunters. This was a plain lie. In fact, hunters had to kill the animal, and needed to kill at least three chirus to get enough shahtoosh for a full shawl.                          
          In this context, the chiru is more like the mink (which also has to be killed to harvest its fur) than the pashmina goat (which can be sheared without harming it). Once, millions of chirus roamed the high Tibetan plateau. Today, the number is down to some thousands. There is a global ban on hunting chirus and trading in shahtoosh. Yet, illegal hunting continues unchecked.                         
          The official ban has simply driven the market for shahtoosh underground. Prices in the black market have gone sky-high ($20,000 or Rs. 9 lakh for one shawl). At these prices, the profitability of poaching overwhelms any official ban. The few existing guards are speedily bribed and become part of the poaching racket. So, the chiru (and the shahtoosh industry of Kashmir) seems doomed to extinction.                                                        Is there a way out? Yes, a very simple one. Instead of continuing with a ban that does not work, the government should permit the chiru to be farmed in Ladakh, with local farmers getting the profits and not poachers. There are many international precedents for saving animals from extinction through farming.        
          The softest, warmest down in Europe was always eider-down, the softest, fluffiest feathers of the elder duck. It was hunted relentlessly for eider-down, and became extinct in some European locations. But in Iceland a law was enacted in 1281 making eider ducks the property of farmers on whose land they bred. In consequence, Iceland’s farmers have always protected their eider ducks from natural predators (foxes, ravens) and poachers. The farmers harvest down from the live birds, and eider-down has become a billion-dollar business in Iceland. The down is stuffed into pillows and quilts and sold at fancy prices.                      
           In Africa, the elephant and rhino were hunted to near-extinction. But today, these animals are protected in large game reserves, many privately owned. Even in government reserves, local people are given a percentage of tourism and hunting fees, to give them a stake in protecting the animals. In consequence, the elephant population has risen so massively as to threaten farmers, so elephants are being culled to control their numbers.                    In South America, the vicuna and alpaca, relatives of the IIama, both yield fine wool. The vicuna was hunted to the verge of extinction despite a ban on all hunting. By contrast, the alpaca population today  runs   into   millions because   it  is farmed. Alpaca farmers and weavers both earn good incomes.   
          In India, Nepal and China, the pashmina   goat   is  farmed,  and  supports thousands of farmers and weavers. The pashmina population is growing and the pashmina trade is flourishing. By contrast the chiru population is shrinking and shahtoosh weavers are becoming extinct.  The solution is obvious. We must allow the chiru to be farmed and harvested. The farmed chiru will have to be killed selectively, just as minks are killed for their fur. Because of this, chiru farming is opposed by two groups of animal lovers.                            
           One group opposes any animal killing on ethical grounds. However, the same opposition is not voiced to killing goats and buffaloes, and using their skin for shoes, wallets, handbags and jackets. Farming chirus will be no more unethical than farming goats for meat and skin.                
           Other critics say that if chiru farms are allowed, poachers will pass off wild chirus as farmed chirus. The risk undoubtedly exists. But it can be reduced by allowing shawls to be woven only within regulated farms, and certifying these as farm-based. Anyway, chirus barely exist in India: they are almost all in Tibet.            
           If chiru-farming spreads quickly, the price of shahtoosh shawls will crash. This will make poaching less profitable and attractive. Low shahtoosh prices will greatly reduce the money-power of poachers that today enables them to buy all officials. In any event, farm rearing will ensure that the chiru flourishes in farms, and does not become extinct.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 11 Sep. 2005


  Is Musk Deer Going the Sariska Tiger Way?
 
Anjali Nauriyal

After tigers, the price of human greed is being paid by yet another animal species - the innocent musk deer. A study by zoologists some time ago stated that over 5,000 adult male deer are slaughtered annually in its Himalayan habitat. The animals are targeted by poachers for the high price the sweet-smelling glands of the deer fetch in the international market.            
         The story is no different at a captive breeding centre at Kanchula Kharak in Chamoli district. The two decade-old centre set-up with a pair of musk deer aiming to increase numbers, is once again left with what it began with, tells Kedarnath Wildlife Division DFO, Ved Pal Singh. There was a time, however, that the number of musk deer here had touched 24.                                  
         As per the 2005 census held in May, 37 musk deer were sighted in the Kedarnath Forest Division. Their number was 61 in 2001 and 63 in 2003. The DFO defends the state of affairs by saying there are usually more deer than the number sighted.                                              
         Musk deer live in high altitude areas that remain cut-off in winters and so it is difficult for forest staff to keep a vigil, said Singh, adding that he had called out for greater infrastructure support. “Keeping an eye on 1,000 square kilometre area is beyond our resources at the moment. The help that we have been getting from the government is not sufficient,” he said. Poachers  set  up  traps beyond the tree lines and take shelter in bushes. To undertake intensive patrolling in severe winters and inclement monsoon, the department also needed to strengthen its intelligence network, he added.                 
        Interestingly, source revealed that only two poaching cases were reported between 2001 and 2003. Citing other reason for the declining numbers, Singh said the animals are unable to adapt to climatic conditions or inadequate sunshine under the thick forest cover. “We have also mooted a proposal to relocate the breeding centre, which is being looked into by a committee,” said Singh.              
       Musk, a strong-smelling secretion produced by the glands of the musk deer, is being used primarily in perfumes and Chinese medicine for over 6,000 years. Musk is used in about 500 traditional Chinese and Korean remedies, making it one of the most common as well as precious medicinal products coming from animal killings. Remedies include those for ailments of nervous system, circulation, heart and lungs and also as a stimulant or sedative. For this reason musk can be sold at three times its value in gold.        
      A range officer offers the last word of caution: “Even though laws exist to conserve this fascinating animal, illegal trade in musk glands (or musk pods) is rampant and dangerously threatening populations of the deer not only in Uttaranchal but all of its habitat in Asia.”
The Times of India (New Delhi), 14 Sep. 2005


  Orissa to Set Up Community Reserve for Blackbucks

Wildlife organisation of the forest department in Orissa has proposed to make Balipadar-Bhetanai area in Ganjam district a “community reserve.” The Balipadar-Bhetanai area is home to over 780 blackbucks.              Once notified it will be the first community reserve in Orissa, where people’s participation will be maximum to protect the local varieties of Krushnasara Mruga or Kala Baudia. The community reserve is a new concept in the amended Wildlife (Protection) Act.                                 
             Prior to the Act’s amendment in 1991, Balipadar-Bhetanai area, comprising 64.21 km, was declared as Game Reserve in 1989 to give protection to the blackbucks and their habitat.                    
           “Since the relevant sections have been deleted in the amended Act, there is a need to give status of community reserve to the area so that blackbucks can be protected properly under the provisions of the Act,” Ghumusar south division divisional forest officer E.I. Yanger Aier said. He also said blackbuck was included in Schedule I of the Act.                
             “Farmers, whose crops have been harmed      by      the      bucks,      will  get compensated. The Blackbuck Protection Committee would also get funds for community development as well as to improve the animal’s habitat,” Aier said. The committee was formed temporarily with representatives from 65 villages nearby.                Despite damages to their crops, people of the area have been protecting the majestic animal with religious sentiments. The animal is associated with their past history and folklore. According to the villagers, a long spell of drought several years ago was over when people of the area sighted a small group of blackbuck. Since then these animals deserve protection.                                          
              Describing protection of blackbuck as an exemplary ‘human-animal relationship’, state chief wildlife warden S.C. Mohanty said it had prompted the department to propose a community reserve.               
              “We will submit a proposal to the government very soon and the wildlife department will provide a big award to the Blackbuck Protection Committee for their dedication,” he said.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 18 Sep. 2005


  Elephants in the Mist
 Suniti Bhushan Datta

The early morning mist rising off the Kabini Reservoir gives the land a surreal look. The sun has not risen yet, and the grassy banks of the reservoir are calm. A dark shape looms out of the bamboo on the fringes of the forest; the mist swirls around as it makes it’s way slowly down to the water’s edge. The elephant has spent the night browsing on the juicy bamboo leaves and needs a drink of water before retreating into the cool depths of the forest. The rising sun soon bums away the last tendrils of mist, beginning another hot day at the Nagarahole National Park in Karnataka.                                                 
               In a country with a population exceeding a billion people, there is scant place for an animal as large as an elephant to survive. Once spanning most of the Indian subcontinent, elephant habitats have shrunk to a few scattered forests in northern, north-eastern and southern India. The healthiest population, by far, exists in the diverse forests of south India. Ranging from dry teak to tropical evergreen, these forests are home to about 15% of the world’s Asiatic elephant population.                  
               Elephant society is typically headed by the eldest and most experienced female in the herd, known as the matriarch. The herd consists of females, their calves and sub-adult animals. Bull elephants are driven out of the herd when they reach maturity and typically live solitarily, away from the herd. The matriarch knows, through years of experience, which areas will have food in a certain season, the location of water during the dry season and places where the herd will be safe.                                       
             Over the centuries, herds have followed rigid migration routes that take them through areas of optimum food and water during the course of the year. These routes are ingrained in the matriarch’s memory. But, in modern times, these routes have been fragmented by man-made obstructions, such as coffee plantations and human settlements. As a result, elephants are increasingly coming into direct conflict with man. The fallout is human casualties by elephants desperate for food and water, and elephant deaths due to poisoning and electrocution. In a land dominated by a large and hungry human population, elephants are seen as pests and have little local support.                
              Despite a bleak prospect, there is hope for these gentle giants. In south India, the elephant has a fighting chance of survival. That chance lies in the Nagarahole National Park, on the border between northern Kerala and Karnataka. This park is a part of what is perhaps the largest area of unbroken elephant habitat in India, known as the Nilgiri Biosphere Reserve. This stretch of forest, covering in excess of 2,000 square kilometers, comprises of the Nagarahole National Park and Bandipur Tiger Reserve in Karnataka, Wynaad Sanctuary in Kerala and the Mudumalai Sanctuary in Tamil Nadu, along with adjacent protected forests.            
            For the Nagarahole elephants, the migration routes go through either Kerala in the south or the Brahmagiri Sanctuary in the west and north. These migration corridors, which are still some what intact, allow the elephants a relatively safe passage between lush monsoon forests in the hills and the grassy banks and abundant water of the Kabini Reservoir in the summer. This reservoir, which forms the southern boundary of the park, provides sustenance for a whole host of animals, including elephants, during the hot and dry summer months.              Every year, around November, and waters of the Kabini Reservoir are gradually drained to provide irrigation to the farmers in the catchments areas around the nearby city of Mysore. The resultant mudflats are rich in silt washed down from the Western Ghats and by the time the forest dries up in April, there is an abundance of fresh, succulent grass to sustain the elephants. It is perhaps a unique phenomenon, where a man-made reservoir, that has drowned some 25 sq. kms of forest, has actually benefited the wildlife of the area. Indeed, the seasonal movements of the Nagarahole herds are intrinsically dependent on the annual drainage cycle of the reservoir.                By the beginning of March, the now lush banks of the reservoir start to fill up with elephants. As summer advances, more and more herds descend from the hills to partake in his annual feast of grass. This is also a social aggregation for the elephants as matriarchs meet each other and the meadows echo with the rumbles, squeaks and trumpets of elephants vocalizations. Calves that were born the previous year are now old enough to eat the soft, nutritious grass and they too get a rare chance to play, tugging at each other’s trunks and tails and butting one another. Younger calves stay close to their mothers or gambol playfully with their elder siblings. Adult elephants are remarkably tolerant of their young. The big bull elephants that are normally solitary mingle with the herds, getting a chance to mate and thereby pass on their genes. Conflicts occasionally occur, as is wont to happen in any society, but they do not last long and peace soon returns to the vast sea of grazing elephants.             Towards the end of May, the grass has worn away, leaving behind short, dry stubs. There too are kicked up by the elephants, exposing bare, dusty patches of soil. Soon the rains will come and the reservoir will fill up once again and it will be time for the matriarchs to lead there herds back into the cool, green heights of the Brahmagiri hills. The lone bull elephants remain behind, to feed on the bamboo and fresh sprout of leaves in the forest. The great elephant congregation dwindles to just a few individuals.    While the Nagarahole National Park is a  safe  haven  for  elephants,  most other reserves are not. Killed for their ivory and continually persecuted by man in a land where they are reversed as a god and were once allowed to roam free, these animals are now regarded as pests. Elephants arriving on the banks of the Kabini frequently carry the wounds and scars of shotgun pellets, fired at them by the irate owners of coffee plantations, over whose land the elephants have trampled through. Many are blinded by pellets and killed or maimed by crude electric fences connected to high-tension cables.       
           However, even as Nagarahole continues to harbour healthy elephant populations, the traditional migration corridors between this park and other areas are being disturbed. As a result, the herds are increasingly becoming an isolated population, which has led to inbreeding, making them vulnerable to disease, and brought them into repeated conflict with humans. Protected areas such as Nagarahole alone are not sufficient for conserving elephants. There is an urgent need for more such areas that can be connected by viable, undisturbed corridors. A sustained and dedicated effort is required to prevent these beautiful, innocent giants from disappearing into extinction.
The Telegraph (Calcutta), 10 Sep. 2005


  Relocate Tigers to Sariska, says Rajasthan Panel

The State Empowered Committee (SEC) on Forest and Wildlife Management, appointed by Rajasthan Chief Minister Vasundhara Raje Sciendia in February, has recommended that tigers be relocated to Sariska.             The panel was set up by the Chief Minister following The Indian Express reports on missing tigers in Sariska and Ranthambhore tiger reserves.                         
          Its report - “Securing the future” - submitted on Tuesday, has called for rehabilitation of villages in Sariska’s Core area to keep “the sanctumsanctorum of the park free from all kinds of disturbances”. Once the villages are removed and an adequate security system put in place, the report proposes relocation of three tigers from Kanha and one from Ranthambhore.    Recommending an immediate “full-fledged high level CB-CID police probe into the connivance and involvement of forest staff of all ranks and the local people and other vested interest groups with the poaching gangs”, the report goes on to slam the state forest department and the Project Tiger for failing to detect the crisis.                                    
          On Sariska, the report observed: “The Project Tiger with all its specified protocols and the modern reporting systems proved to be woefully lacking, and therefore these inputs from Project Tiger came to naught. In fact, the ‘early warning systems’ created by Project Tiger failed to deliver”.                                
         Seeking immediate action and fixing of responsibility for the decline in the tiger population in Ranthambhore from 47 in 2004 to 26 in 2005, the report points out that “as late as (in) March 2005, an inspection report  by  Project  Tiger  stated that there were no tigers missing in Ranthambhore and all monitoring and early warning systems were in place”. It goes on to note that “the systems put in place for monitoring Ranthambhore tigers were either non-existent or failed to deliver”.                                                     
         For Keoladeo National Park, the report recommends ensuring suitable water reservation in the Panchana dam, so the park receives 550 million cft of water by mid-July.                                               
        The SEC has discouraged any efforts to make the piped water the mainstay - as it would cause “irreparable loss” to the wetland eco-system.                        
        The SEC has also recommended setting up of a State Wildlife Crime Bureau in the police headquarters at Jaipur and a state-of-the-art training centre for all forest staff..
Indian Express (New Delhi), 09 Sep. 2005


  Sariska to get Back Big Cats
 Saurabh Sinha

Rajasthan government has finally decided to reintroduce tigers in the Sariska reserve forest. According to the plan, big cats from Ranthambore or MP’s Kanha reserve would be shifted to Sariska but only after it is made safe for them, state’s Chief Wildlife Warden R.N. Mehrotra told TOI. He, however, didn’t give any timeframe but assured that “this would happen soon”.    “We have a plan that would be implemented with the help of experts and the Wildlife Institute of India (WII). With the Centre’s support, we will first do some groundwork like diverting traffic from the prime valley  and also relocate villages that are situated inside the forest,” Mehrotra said.                                                
          The Sariska reserve has 28 villages and in the first phase about 15 would be shifted from the crore area. He added that the state government has worked out a five-year plan to remove all villages from the sanctuary.           The Centre also seems to be enthusiastic about the plan. “WII had conducted a feasibility report regarding reintroducing tigers in Sariska. We’ve asked the state about the requirements. Once we get a strong proposal for ensuring an undisturbed habitat and protection from all threats, we will support the project in a scientific manner,” Project Tiger director Rajesh Gopal said. He added that the WII had suggested that five tigers be introduced in Sariska once the area in declared safe.                                       
          When P.M. Manmohan Singh had visited Ranthambore some months back, the state government had sought financial help for relocating villagers and taking some other steps. Now, the ministry is going to ask the state how  much  financial support it would require for reintroducing tigers.                                                            The Sariska Park has been closed for taking some corrective steps and is likely to reopen by October-end.
The Times of India (New Delhi), 10 Sep. 2005


 Curb Human Activity Near Sariska: Panel

The empowered committee on forest and wildlife, appointed by the state government, has recommended that the 28 villages coming under Sariska sanctuary should be shifted elsewhere and human activities be curbed immediately.            
        Committee chairman V.P. Singh submitted a nine-chapter report, which puts forward many recommendations to chief minister Vasundhara Raje on Tuesday.                        
           It was suggested that neither a new hotel be allowed to come up in and around Ranthambhors, nor should permission be granted for capacity addition in existing hotels.After studying the problems faced by Keoladeo national park at Bharatkpur, which is a UNESCO heritage site, the empowered committee suggested that before providing Chambal water to the national park through pipelines, its likely effect on ecology and environment should be analysed.                                                         
          The report has suggested various steps to be taken in sanctuaries to prevent poaching, new technological measures to be adopted for wildlife census and steps to be taken for relocating tigers in Sariska, which is devoid of any tiger population because of poaching. The committee, which was formed in February this year, made an extensive study by visiting tiger reserves. It found that there was an urgent need to draw a master plan for religious places and also places of heritage value in Ranthambhore. It felt the need for a similar master plan for Khandar and Udgir’s forts and for Keoladevi temple falling in the Ranthambhore national park vicinity.           
         One of the prime concerns of the empowered committee has been to revive Sariska by reintroducing tigers. This has never taken place anywhere in the world. It is a big challenge before the state and the country for which a well conceived coordinated strategy, backed by sound science and political will is needed. The current crisis has exemplified the gross inadequacy of field formations as well as administrative setup at the state-level to effectively deal with matters both in the field and at policy levels. A systematic restructuring and overhaul of present organizational structure of the wildlife wing is urgently needed in order to enable it to effectively fulfil its mandate and responsibilities.                                      
         In the report, specific recommendations have been made to improve all aspects of protected area management, including protection and intelligence gathering, rehabilitation of villages, research and monitoring, tourism, population estimation and dealing with traditional hunting communities.The empowered committee has also suggested the formation of a ‘Wildlife Conservation Trust Fund’, with the chief minister as its chairperson.
Hindustan Times (New Delhi), 08 Sep. 2005


With the help of Wildlife Institute of India (WII), Dehradun, the Project Tiger Directorate will launch a countrywide tiger census this November to bring out a clearer picture of tiger numbers in the country.             
           A team of international observers will be invited by the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests to be part of this exercise, which will go up to February 2006. The census will begin on November 15.                             Talking to TOI here on Friday, B.C. Chowdhury, a senior scientist of the WII, said in October, the WII would train the spearhead team of scientists who would carry out the census. “Director, Project Tiger, and his team will also participate in the census,” he said.                        
         He said states would be free to invite any expert they wished to for the exercise, which would be conducted for eight days at each location identified by the team.                                               
        “New techniques which will be used, will take the focus away from the pugmark technique,” said Chowdhury. “The      revised       methodology      being developed by the WII is not for counting tigers individually.”                                         
           He said idea, behind the fresh census was to determine the prey base status of various locations and study the habitat conditions. “We will also see whether there is a breeding population of tigers or not in the areas being surveyed.”        
          Chowdhury    said     the    country would be divided into landscapes and density factors would be studied in accordance with the landscape. “Density will be judged even on the smallest level, the beat level.”           Uttaranchal’s chief wildlife warden Srikant Chandola said the new methodology would enable experts to get valuable information. “Uttaranchal will hold the census sometime in January 2006.”            
         Former chief wildlife warden Anand Singh Negi said a good estimate of tiger numbers in any area could be made by their stripes, markings and faces. “The real problem of counting is not in the protected areas but in the areas outside the protected areas.”
The Times of India (New Delhi), 10 Sep. 2005


  Indian Tiger Skins Flooding Tibet Blackmarket
 Jay Mazoomdaar

Despite the red alert sounded by the Ministry of Environment and Forests across the country, the trade in tiger and other big cat skins from India is flourshing a alarmingly in Tibet and adjoining areas of China. With increased suspplies of tiger, leopard and other skins, many new shops have sprung up in what is arguably the world’s single largest wildlife blackmarket.                                       
         These are some of the startling findings of an ongoing survey conducted by the London-based Environmental Investigative Agency (EIA) with the help of the Wildlife Protection Society of Indian (WPSI). The survey report will be released later this month but sources confirmed that the situation has only worsened since October 2003 when China’s Anti-Smuggling Bureau intercepted a truck in their “Tibetan Autonomous Region” that was carrying a consignment of 31 tiger, 581 leopard and 778 otter skins from India.                          
         “This has been an extensive survey and we also covered new areas. We will start analysing our data before we finalise the report,” EIA’s senior campaigner Debbie Banks told The Indian Express. Conducted last month, the key findings of the recent survey are:                                                
· Both the open sale and use of fresh tiger, leopard and otter skins is even more widespread than last year.
· All dealers the team talked to said the skins had come from India.                   
· In Lhasa, many new shops were openly selling tiger and leopard skin chubas – a traditional Tibetan outfit. At one shop, the team found three fresh tiger skins – priced up to Rs. 5.4 lakh each – and seven fresh leopard skins for sale. All these skins were said to have been smuggled from India.                                        
· Most Tibetans wearing chubas claimed they had purchased the outfits during the past two seasons.
· Only 10 shops in the main Barkhor circuit stocked 24 tiger skin chubas. Another 20 stocked 54 leopard skin chubas. There are a total of 46 shops in the market.                                                          
· A large number  of   leopard   and snow leopard skins were also found on the streets of Linxia.
· The over-all situation is much worse than what was found during the EIA survey last year.  “The survey confirms without doubt that there is large-scale poaching of tigers and leopards in India whose skins are smuggled to Tibet,” said WPSI’s Belinda Wrights, also a member of Rajasthan’s State Empowered Committee (SEC) on Forest and Wildlife Management.                                            
          Wrights  has  pointed  out  some  of the preliminary findings in the panel’s report that was presented to Chief Minister Vasundhara Raje this evening in Jaipur. Among other recommendations, the SEC report has emphasized the need to curb cross-border smuggling in wildlife objects.      
         “We were told that the Tibetan chuba is exempted from the law even if it is adorned with an entire tiger skin. In Linxia, traders claimed that in the Hui Autonomous Prefecture of Gansu Province, there is a special policy that allows them to openly sell skins,” wrote WPI’s Wrights in the SEC report.                      
        The information gathered by the EIA/WPSI team has been passed on to the Chinese authorities. A delegation from India – a MOEF and a CBI official – was in China a couple of weeks back to attend a CITES meet. They were also briefed about the findings at an EIA presentation.
Indian Express (New Delhi), 08 Sep. 2005


  Tiger Census May Spring Surprises
 Yudhajit Shankar Das

With the Ministry of Environment and Forests jolted out of its slumber by the Sariska debacle, a transparent procedure has been drawn up to conduct the next tiger census, due in November.                     
          “For the very first time internal and external observers, people who are experts in the field, will be monitoring the census procedure,” Mr. Ganga Singh, joint director, Project Tiger, said. Till now the state forest department used to collect the data and analyse them with to checks from the Centre on how far the figures made available were correct.                          
            The Union Minister For Environment and Forests; Mr. A. Raja, said on Tuesday that the Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun, would also be entrusted with the responsibility of carrying out the census from this year. WII organized a one-day workshop on 29 August in New Delhi, which was attended by forest department authorities from the states. “We will also have several regional workshops in September and October before the census begins to train and sensitise the forest department staff,” said the director, Wildlife Institute of India, Mr. P.R. Sinha.                                           
            Mr. Sinha told The Statesman: “This year’s census will provide excellent information base which will help in framing policies for the future.” He added that till now the numbers of ‘big cats’ provided by the states were not accurate because they gave the total estimates, instead of giving break-ups for each sector/section. “The Tiger Task Force report also recommended the method that we will be using now,” Mr. Sinha said. The method has three levels, and has been under field testing in the Satpura-Maikal area of Madhya Pradesh, for the last one-and-a-half years. To homogenize the area from where the forest officials would collect data it has been divided into beats (of 15-20 sq. kms each). The initial data will be collected by the pugmark method. In   the    second   level   the   area  will  be stratified on the basis of the numbers of tigers inhabiting it. The third level will see experts intensively researching the stratum, beginning with pugmarks, digital photography of the pugmarks, camera trapping, to scad sample analysis.                      
             Work has begun in right earnest, and a team of experts have visited the tiger reserves and filed preliminary reports, based on guidelines drawn-up by the International Union of Conservation of Natural resources, Mr. Ganga Singh said.   Mr. Raja also spoke of creating a Wildlife Crime Bureau on the lines of the Central Bureau of Intelligence, that will be headed  by   an   I.P.S   officer,  to  prevent terrorist infiltration in the forests. Some of the tiger reserves like Namdhapa, Manas in the North-East and Nagarjunasagar, Palamau and Indravati have been ravaged due to terrorist and Naxalite activities respectively. This is probably the first time that the Centre is actively participating in the census process, which, till now, had been solely maintained by the various state governments.                                                          
            “The figures that were reported were in many cases not biologically feasible,” says the Coordinator of the Tiger Conservation Project of the World Wildlife Fund for Nature, Brig Ranjit Talwar. It was during the last days of the mentor of Project Tiger, Mrs. Indira Gandhi, that the gross misrepresentation of tiger figures by wildlife authorities started. But after her, there was a lack of political will to do anything substantial and the worst the degeneration in the conservation was reached, Brig Talwar said. This census with all the promised methodology and transparency is bound to spring some surprises.
The Statesman (New Delhi), 05 Sep. 2005


  Uneasy existence
 Meena Menon

At dusk, the state transport bus disgorges people returning from work in Khatkali village in the Melghat Tiger Reserve. “We go everywhere looking for work,” says Gamba Belsare.             
          Despite this, he and other villagers are quite happy with their existence in the forest. They said they had many facilities, apart from water and fuel. Every year, with dwindling jobs, the people of Khatkali clear forestland and plant some crops. This year is no different. “We get about five to six quintals per acre of jowar which lasts for six months,” says Belsare. According to Badu Jamunkar, “There is no other way for us. We don’t have any land and little food. We often sleep on an empty stomach. There are malnourished children too.”            
         However, in the past, the Forest Department punished people for this. Very few have land rights. Dayaram Jamunkar defiantly adds, “How can they punish us? It’s our land, which the Forest Department has taken over. We only want to grow food to eat. We are not doing anything wrong. We are also constantly accused of stealing firewood.”                                  
Near the core area
                         
         Living in the forest has problems too. People have to stay up all night to ensure that animals do not destroy their crops. If clearing forests is an issue in Khatkali, then in Dhargad it is the poisoning of deer. Early in July, a sambar was killed at Koktu near Dhargad and one person was arrested. Before that two chital or spotted deer were poisoned. Someone kept a pot of urea, which leached into the water around the land pump. The chitals drank this and died. This village has been settled since 1964 and it is near the core area of the Reserve. “The Forest Department gave us land and built homes for us to stay here and look after the forest. They also gave us work. But after this tiger project, there is nothing for us. We have to steal firewood and clear land for agriculture. We are treated unjustly,” says Pundalik Baliram Godmale.                                
        The Korkus and the Gawlis inhabit this village. People complained that the Forest Department allows Kathiawadi cattle as well as cattle from a dairy to graze in the forest. Over the years, there has been a lot of bitterness. “The Forest Department has taught us to steal,” alleges one villager. In June, two persons were arrested for the poisoning of the deer and let off on bail. Villagers deny they poisoned the deer but they admitted to eating it. “We love meat and we did inform the Forest Department, which did not move away the carcass, so we ate it,” chuckles one villager.                                        
        The people feel they have bigger problems. They don’t understand why the Forest Department does not permit the killing of wild boar, which destroys their crops. Both Khatkali and Dhargad are part of the19 villages, which are to be relocated from the Melghat Tiger Reserve in Maharashtra’s Amravati district. Three villages have already been moved out and there are mixed reactions among the relocated people.                                    
        In Dhargad they have already been shown land, which people have approved. “We are quite keen on leaving the forest. The Forest Department suspects us of killing animals. Now they even have military men to keep vigil on us,” said Godmale. However, Vatsala Deokar fears that if they leave the forest, they may have to pay for many things they now take for granted. During the rains, the forests of Melghat Tiger Reserve are greener. The air is full of bird cries and one may even spot a few deer. There has been no detected case of tiger poaching since five years but there is no room for complacence, according to the field director of the reserve, Nitin Kakodhar. Here, other issues are as important and linked to the tiger’s survival.            
Reserve is understaffed                                  
         The Reserve, which has about 70 tigers, is under staffed with 206 guards and 72 foresters against a sanctioned strength of 600. Of late the prey base is the increasing target. One of the first nine Tiger Reserves included in Project Tiger in 1973, the 1,676 sq. km. Reserve comprises the Gughamal National Park, which is the core area, the Melghat Tiger Sanctuary and a denotified area of 500 sq. km. area called the multiple use area. Kishore Rithe of Nature Conservation Society, Amravati, says, “You don’t need organized gangs from outside for poisoning water holes. In May, a water hole was poisoned in the Chaurakund Range and sure enough we found several species of animals and birds dead. People dig up the banks of the water holes and place endosulfan or urea there.” Sambar are either poisoned or hunted by dogs.                                          
Problem of cattle
                                 
         However, the Forest Department is increasingly facing people’s anger when it tries to catch the  culprits.  In  Dhargad  for instance, when the department went to make an arrest, the people threatened to set fire to the jungle. While parts of Melghat are hilly, agriculture is confined to the small plains area. This is where the 19 villages are located mostly and that is why they need to be relocated, argues Rithe. Kakodhar said that as per records, 30,000 heads of cattle are grazing on the plains, but the number could be more. He agreed that cattle was one of the major problems in the forest and to get a good flush of grass, often the grazers set the forest on fire. He said the poaching of herbivores had to be curbed and some ex-army men had been appointed from July 1 to keep vigil. The availability of fodder even for herbivores was under threat and he feared  this stress could affect their breeding, further affecting the already low prey base. All these varied stresses have an impact on the tiger.                                                          
         Rithe points out that tigers have become nocturnal and sightings are very rare. Cattle pressure was tremendous in the forest and there were about 1,50,000 heads of cattle, as against about 8,000 herbivores, he estimates, which speaks poorly of the Reserve. In this complex situation, conservation strategies have to be balanced in the interests of the people and the animals. With the forest department, conservationists and human rights activists at loggerheads on this issue, no easy solutions are at hand.
 
The Hindu (New Delhi), 11 Sep. 2005


  For Claws, Lions Being Poisoned in Gir Forest
 Haresh Pandya

Another big cat is under threat. Poachers are killing the Asiatic lions of Gir by poisoning them. At least one lioness and five lions were found dead in the Dhari and Khamba jungles in the last seven days. At a dozen lions were poisoned this year.                                        
          A lioness was found in a critical condition on Wednesday. She died at the animal care center in Sasan, the heart of Gir, on Saturday. The same day, two burnt carcasses of lions were found. Around the same time, the Gir Nature Youth Club (GNYC) reported two more deaths. On Sunday, yet another lion was reported dead. The startling similarity among these carecasses was that they were without claws. Forest officers raided a temple near Hirava in Gir on September 12 and arrested three people for poisoning lions and removing their claws. Thirty-one claws were recovered from them. There’re villages on the periphery of Gir where lions venture regularly. Poachers try to lure them into the nearby hamlets of Hirava, Gadhiya, Virpur and Madhavpur and then kill them. Six years ago, an interstate gang of poachers was caught from Gadhiya.                           
         There is a forest chowky at Hirava. The staff works round the clock. But incidents of poaching keep happening from time to time. On August 3, the carcass of a lion was found at Hirava. The animal was without fifteen of its 18 claws.  
          In the same area, Lions killed several domestic animals on July 25. Later, some poachers mixed poison in the kill when the lions went for a stroll in the jungle. The forest authorities got to know of the poachers’ plan. But it was too late – the culprits had managed to flee. But the lions were saved.                                
          “There is a big demand for genuine lion claws as there is a flourishing business of animal teeth. Poachers don’t hesitate to kill lions by injecting poison in their kill or by giving them poisoned prey,” states wildlife expert Indraneel Parmar.                                     
         “Poisoning of lions to remove their claws is an old practice in Gir. Forest authorities need to intensify patrolling in the sensitive areas  where  lions  roam  and poachers camp. It’s high time they made a thorough search for the real offenders and conducted an impartial inquiry into the whole scandal. It doesn’t help nabbing one or two suspects and making a big show of it and then allowing them to go scot-free for want of evidence,” says Amit Jethwa, president, GNYC.
Hindustan Times (New Delhi), 20 Sep. 2005


The roar of lions could drown the sound of gunfire in Chambal. The Central Zoo Authority is considering a proposal of the Uttar Pradesh government to set up a lion safari park in the Chambal ravines-home to the dreaded bandit gangs.                          
          According to senior environment ministry officials, the Uttar Pradesh government has forwarded a proposal to set up a lion sanctuary in Etawah, the home town of chief minister Mulayam Singh Yadav.                    But is this a desperate measure to wrest control of the valley from the dacoits? While the ministry considers the proposal, there is a whisper campaign afoot that the government wants to create a fear of the animals among bandits, which will force them to leave Uttar Pradesh for the ravines in Madhya Pradesh.            The central Uttar Pradesh area is notorious for crime. According  to  official records, Etawah has seen some 4,000 kidnappings and 180 murders in the past five years.                                                  
          The state’s chief wildlife conservator Mohammad Ehsan scoffs at the claim. “I fail to understand how it has been construed that the lions would scare away bandits from that area.”                        
         The plan to develop a lion safari park has been in the pipeline for a long time, he said. “The proposal forwarded by the UP government says that the green belt in Chambal and the ravines near Etawan can be home to lions,” an official said.                 
         The government has selected a 150-hectare area on the outskirts of Etawah town for the park. The initial cost of the project is estimated to be Rs. 10 crore.   Ministry officials say the proposal is in the advanced stage of consideration.
Hindustan Times (New Delhi), 05 Sep. 2005


  A Jewel Crafted by Nature
 
G. Ananthakrishnan

Just how the last remaining natural spaces in the country should be preserved is now the theme of a polarising debate in the conservation community. Science-based conservation advocates find themselves in a confrontational situation with activists who believe animals and humans can co-exist in a wild setting. There is little doubt, however, about where Bittu Sahgal, the founder-editor of Sanctuary magazine comes from when he makes an impassioned plea to preserve a precious piece of the wilderness in The Kaziranga Inheritance, a book that is a tribute to a famous reserve.                                  
           He and lead author Ranjit Barthakur have documented the uniqueness of Kaziranga and a dedicated group of photographers have enlivened their writings with handsome full-page colour plates. This is more an evocative journey through a small fragment of a once-rich past where the one-horned rhinoceros, the tiger and a host of other animal and bird species have miraculously survived over the decades.                  
Visual narrative
                                      
            A book such as this one, sweeping across the panorama of life in Kaziranga, must naturally provide a visual narrative that is as rich as the landscape – and it does not disappoint, though no one can be blamed for asking for more. After all, the National Park has recorded 505 species of birds, some 100 of them migrants, and that is a breathtaking tally for an ornithologist in a single reserve. There are also 440 species of plants here. Figuring on the long list of birds, reproduced in the book, are the beautiful Bengal Florican and the Oriental Pied Hornbill. The history of this area takes the reader back in time the early part of the 20th Century and the first attempts at securing a future for the rhinoceros. It all began with the strenuous efforts of J.C. Arbuthnott, the officiating Commissioner of the Assam Valley Districts, to get the chief commissioner to announce a ban on hunting and to protect three distinctly well- endowed areas as reserved forest; in 1916, Kaziranga became a game sanctuary. That this was achieved with little additional persuasion in a province where the lucrative tea industry had already taken root should provide a sobering perspective to present-day policymakers and bureaucrats at the Ministry of Environment and Forests.
Global Showpiece
                             
        Kaziranga is a global showpiece, a World Heritage Site. It seeks to provide more space today for its megafauna – the rhinos, elephants and tigers – to cross over to safe territory during the monsoon and floods that move south. The animals are driven by the waters to seek safety on higher ground, passing through Haldhibari in the Karbi Anglong Hills and the Panbari and Kachanjhuri Reserved Forests. The crossing is a terrifying ordeal for the protected denizens of the Park: in 1998, some 600 animals drowned. Man-made tragedy also strikes many others who die each on National Highway 37 (on the southern side of the National Park) including tigers, after being hit by automobiles.                                                            
       Bittu Sahgal and his colleagues give vent to their anguish in the book in some detail, lamenting the weak responses to some of the challenges that Kanziranga and indeed all protected area face. The overall thread that runs through this large-format volume, however, is one of celebration, expressing great joy at the survival of the national park and the need to look to the future. The tough reputation of the Park in dealing with poachers, in contrast to most other protected areas where armed patrolling is woefully inadequate, would seem adequate reason for jubilation. It become illegal to hunt in Kaziranga as early as 1908, as the authors find from official records, and a particularly effective Chief Conservator, A.J.W. Milroy (who had already made a name for himself by reducing the trauma involved in capture of elephants) took on poaching gangs with good results. Decades later, Kaziranga tries to maintain its traditionally unforgiving approach to poaching, with a great  deal  of  help  from the citizen sector.                                             
          The book tracks two key conservation issues that form part of the current national debate: greater use of science to help these protected area regenerate and the role of communities in helping these wild places survive. One of the leading investigators in the field, Dr. K. Ullas Karanth has contributed a chapter, ‘The Science of Conservation’ dealing with the effectiveness of camera traps to sample tiger populations. It would be of interest to wildlife watchers that Kaziranga has higher tiger densities compared to most other reserves. ‘The Human Factor’, a chapter analyzing the impact of a growing human population that is part of a consuming economy on three sides of the National Park raises the contradictions that mark official policy. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has, in his foreword, expressed support to the National Park, acknowledging its timeless value. Congress (I) president Sonia Gandhi is even more forthright in a note published in the book, expressing worry at the “greed of city dwellers increasingly feeding off the forests” and commending the “far-sighted, stringent and successfully enforced conservation measures” in Kaziranga. If such unequivocal policy support to science is sustained, the Ministry of Environment and Forests can be persuaded to fulfill its mandate to protect not merely Kaziranga but all key habitats in the country. Many more such celebratory works can then document the beauty of the land and its wondrous creatures.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 13 Sep. 2005


Haryana Seeks Rs. 28 lakh for Wildlife Census
 Ruchika M. Khanna

The Forest Department, Haryana, has demanded a sum of Rs. 28 lakh from the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests, in order to carry out the census of wildlife in the state. The wildlife census will be carried out in January, 2006.             
       Officials in the Forest Department informed TNS that a meeting of state wildlife officials was held with officials of the ministry and the Wildlife Institute of India recently. The meeting was held to work out a schedule for training wildlife staff in the state, so that they could further train the junior staff to carry out the census.          The Wildlife Institute of India will train the core group of wildlife officials from Haryana in December this year. Aided by the wildlife Institute, the census of wild animals in all major forest belts of the state will be carried out. This wildlife census will provide a base for environmentalists and forest officials to have estimates of wildlife population in the state.                                                        
        The money sought from the Ministry of Environment and Forests will be used for buying two pickup vans for the census staff, a global positioning system, binoculars, cameras and other infrastructure to be used by the census staff, including tented accommodation for their stay when the 10-day census is on.        
        The census work, inform officials, will be carried out in over 950 sq. km. forest area, including the Kalesar Wildlife Sanctuary and its surrounding areas like Kalsia Forest in Yamunanagar, Morni, Bir Shikargah and the Raipur Rani area in Panchkula and Aravali forest belt in Gurgaon and Mahendragarh.                           
        It may be noted that census of wildlife in Haryana was done in 2002, and again in 2003-04. However, both the census reports have not been published. The census of wildlife conducted in 2002 was accepted by the department, except for the census of leopards and other wild cats. The pugmark traces of these big cats collected on plaster moulds were not accepted by the Wildlife Institute of India, “because these traces were not visible”.        
        The census estimates put the number of sambars at about 740, barking deers at 1031, wild boars at about 2300, gorals around 2850, chitals at 54; 311 chinkaras and about 250 langoors. This census also put the blue bull population at 38,000, which was considered  to  be  on  a higher scale.                                                 
       A census was ordered again in 2003-04. After the census counting was complete, the compilation of census data could not be carried out because of frequent changes in officers assigned to do the task.         
       The census to be carried out now will identify leopards, sambhars, chitals, barking dogs, black deer, blue bulls and chinkaras.                                                       
       This census will also include a count of the actual blue bull population in the state, which has become a cause of concern for the environmentalists as the sightings of this antelope has been declining.
The Tribune (Chandigarh), 13 Sep. 2005


अपने देश की हरी-भरी धरती पर उछलने-कूदने वाले कंगारुओं के मनमोहक दृश्य आपको शायद कोरी कल्पना लगे, लेकिन एक जमाने में यह हकीकत थी। आज से साढ़े पांच करोड़ वर्ष पहले भारत की भूमि पर कंगारू उसी तरह विचरण करते थे, जैसे आज आस्ट्रेलिया और दक्षिण अमेरिका में।     हाल ही में गुजरात के सूरत जिले की वास्तान लिग्नाइट खान से मिले करीब साढ़े पांच करोड़ वर्ष पुराने अवशेषों से इस बात की पुष्टि हुई है। दुनिया भर में स्तनपायी थलचर जीवों के विकासक्रम की कड़ी जोड़ने वाले यह अवशेष खोज निकाले हैं भूवैज्ञानिक सुनील वाजपेई तथा उनकी शोधकर्ता टीम ने। यह दुर्लभ खोज दुनिया भर के जीवाश्म वैज्ञानिकों को आकर्षित कर रही है।                      
            
वैज्ञानिक टीम को कंगारू के अवशेष के रूप में मोरल दांत मिले हैं। वैज्ञानिक वाजपेई का कहना है कि हर प्रजाति के दांतों की संरचना एक-दूसरे से बिल्कुल जुदा होती है। दांतों के आधार पर किसी भी जाति विशेष का पता लगाया जा सकता है। एशिया में अब तक सिर्फ कुछ एक जगहों पर ही इस विशिष्ट स्तनपायी के अवशेष पाए गए हैं। कंगारू के सबसे पुराने अवशेष चीन में मिले हैं, जो दस करोड़ साल पुराने हैं।                                     
           
भूवैज्ञानिक सुनील वाजपेई आई.आई.टी. रुड़की के अर्थसाइंसेज डिपार्टमेंट में कार्यरत हैं तथा पिछले कई वर्षों से व्हेल मछलियों पर शोध कर रहे हैं। उनके द्वारा खोजे गए व्हेल के अवशेषों ने समूची दुनिया  के  जीवविज्ञानियों  तथा  भूवैज्ञानिकों में हलचल मचा दी थी। उन्होंने बताया कि सूरत में हुई खोज के दौरान कंगारू सहित घोड़ा, जेब्रा जैसी 12 विभिन्न स्तनपायी जीवों की प्रजातियों के अवशेष मिले हैं। वह बताते हैं कि साढ़े पांच करोड़ साल पहले कंगारू विकासक्रम की प्रारंभिक अवस्था में रहे होंगे। ये आकार में काफी छोटे तथा आज के कंगारुओं के मुकाबले काफी भिन्नता लिए होंगे। आज से 15 करोड़ वर्ष पहले इंडियन प्लेट यानी भारतीय प्रायद्वीप गोंडवाना लैंड का हिस्सा थी।              
            
अफ्रीका, अंटार्कटिका, आस्ट्रेलिया, मेडागास्कर तथा दक्षिण अमेरिका भी इसी लैंड के हिस्सा थे। धीरे-धीरे अन्य भूखंडों के साथ भारतीय प्रायद्वीप भी गोंडवाना लैंड से अलग होना शुरू हुआ। इंडियन प्लेट की यह यात्रा करोड़ों वर्षों तक दक्षिण से उत्तर की ओर चलती रही। करीब साड़े पांच करोड़ वर्ष पहले इंडियन प्लेट, एशियन प्लेट से जा टकरायी और भूखंडों की इस टक्कर से हिमालय का जन्म हुआ। माना जाता है कि इससे  इंडियन  प्लेट पर स्तनपायी थलचर जीवों का आवागमन एशियासे शुरू हो गया। डा. वाजपेई एवं उनकी टीम की खोज से यह सवाल उठता है कि कंगारू के पूर्वज भारत में इस टक्कर के बाद आए या पहले से ही मौजूद थे। समूचे एशिया से कंगारू क्यों विलुप्त हो गए और आस्ट्रेलिया एवं दक्षिण अमेरिका में ही क्यों सिमटकर रह गए। यह सवाल दुनिया में काफी चर्चा का विषय रहा है। भारतीय खोज से इस गुत्थी को सुलझाने में मदद मिलेगी।
दैनिक जागरण (देहरादून), 02 Sep. 2005


 

The time has come for “green building technology” to benefit the middle and lower classes, besides rural India, in order to achieve goals of energy independence and housing for all, President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam said on Thursday. The aim of every individual should be to conserve at least 10to 15% of energy and water, he said.            Delivering the inaugural address at ‘Green Building Congress 2005’ here, Dr. Kalam said, taking green technology to the people was key to harnessing the benefits of development and modern technology and preserving the environment. It was important that all buildings should not just be environment friendly but also aesthetically beautiful and economically viable. “A transparent cost benefit analysis will bring many people into the movement to the green building revolution.”
Certification programme
             
           Suggesting that a nationwide certification programme for builders and architects for their green and safety awareness be launched, the President said: “The congress should document the experience, both successes and problems, from Hyderabad and Gurgaon green buildings. This may lead to green building code evolution and a process for the best practices. While doing so, the rating systems for green buildings developed by The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI), including the Indian codes, standards and best practices, may also be taken into account.”                                 
           Stating that green technology of the future would have a significant component of high tech and cutting edge research    and    development   in  material science, Dr. Kalam said: “Water harvesting and recycling will make every building less dependent on external water supply, thus reducing the load on the town and city resources. The green tech itself will become sustainable only when it reaches the rural population.”          
Cutting energy losses
                      
           “There are about 300 million people in the middle income group and about 260 million people are living below poverty line. If we could reach the technology to them, the massive construction effort will form the backbone of our economy,” he said, adding that for energy independence, the need was to cut down energy losses and accessing technologies that would provide reliable, affordable, renewable and environment friendly sustainable energy.                   
          Speaking at the function, Indian Green Building Council chairman Parasu Raman R. asked the Government to make it mandatory for the buildings about 2,000sq. ft. to incorporate minimum green features and at the State level, the urban development authorities would come up with green measures.              
          At the function, the President presented prizes to three architecture students – Elizabeth Alex, Madhavi Jain and Sonal Jawale – for their essays on green building. Awards were also presented for various green buildings.        
          The two-day international conference on green building is organized by the Confederation of Indian Industry and the Indian Green Building Council, which is hosting a four-day exhibition and a seminar on green buildings and homes.
The Hindu (New Delhi), 16 Sep. 2005


State Gets Exotic Tree from China

The Himalayan Forest Research Institute has introduced Paulownia fortunei, a fast growing exotic agroforestry species from China in the hills of Himachal Pradesh and Jammu and Kashmir.               
           The Institute supplied quality seedlings of silver fir, spruce and deodar to the State Forest Department for field plantation. All these conifers are excellent timber species. It also planted 1000 seedlings of silver fir and spruce raised in root trainers, at Shilaroo in Shimla to evaluate their performance in forestry plantations for further recommendations to the forest departments.                             
          Mr. Surinder Kumar, Director of the institute, said here yesterday that about 500 quality seedlings of Paulownia fortunei in the two states had been supplied to the Forest Department. It would help supplement the wood requirements for making boxes for fruits and vegetables besides providing fuel and fodder in future. Over 50 seedlings of the species were planted in the fields at Baragaon in Shimla district.     
          The institute also planted 25,000 quality seedlings of Jatropha curcas, a bio-diesel yielding forestry species, to evaluate its performance in grassland, degraded land, bunds of agriculture fields and open forests of lower and mid Himalayan regions of Himachal Pradesh. Nursery and planting techniques would be demonstrated to the end users through these plantations to motivate the rural people in exploring the species for commercial purposes. Similarly, 1500 seedlings of wild apricot, chulli-oil yielding variety had been planted in the field to establish model plantations and extend nursery and plantation techniques of wild apricot to local communities in Himachal Pradesh.                                     
          To optimize the productivity and augement rural income, the institute has established different intercropping models of commercially important medicinal plants like Aconitum heterophyllum (patish), useful in many stomach problems, angelica glauca (chora), Picrorhiza kurooa (karu) and Polygonatum verticilatum (salam mishri).
The Tribune (Chandigarh), 08 Sep. 2005


एफ.आर.आई. में हाई टैक नर्सरी व प्लांटेशन मैनेजमेंट ट्रेनिंग कोर्स शुरू

वन अनुसंधान संस्थान के सभागार में वन संवर्धन प्रभाग द्वाराहाई-टैक नर्सरी एवं प्लांटेशन मैनेजमेंट ट्रेनिंग कोर्स का आज शुभारंभ किया गया। जिसका उदघाटन संस्थान के निदेशक डा. एस.एस. नेगी ने किया। इस प्रशिक्षण कार्यक्रम में देश के विभिन्न हिस्सों के प्रमुख संस्थानों से अधिकारी भाग ले रहे हैं।                                  
      उल्लेखनीय है इस तरह के दस दिवसीय कार्यक्रम का आयोजन वन अनुसंधान संस्थान में पहली बार हो रहा है जिसमें उच्चतर तकनीकों का समावेश किया गया है। अपने उदघाटन भाषण में निदेशक डा. नेगी ने बीजों की गुणवत्ता पर जोर देने की बात कही, इसके अतिरिक्त उन्होंने टाल-प्लान्टिंग की महत्ता दर्शायी।                            
            तदोपरांत दीपक खन्ना, प्रमुख, विस्तार प्रभाग ने संस्थान के विभिन्न प्रशिक्षण कार्यक्रमों के बारे में जानकारी दी। तत्पश्चात प्रशिक्षण कार्यक्रम निदेशक डा. राजीव श्रीवास्तव ने प्रशिक्षुओं को अधिकतम व्यावहारिक ज्ञान उपलब्ध कराने का आश्वासन दिया। अंत में कार्यक्रम समन्वयक कु. अमिता तोमर  ने  कार्यक्रम  के  अंतर्गत  होने  वाली विभिन्न गतिविधियों का उल्लेख किया। कार्यक्रम वैज्ञानिक मनीषा थपलियाल ने बीजों के रखरखाव व भंडारण के बारे में तथ्यों का उल्लेख किया और श्रीमती नीलू गेरा’, आई.एफ.एस. ने पौधशाला में उपयोग आने वाले उपकरणों और तकनीकों के बारे में विस्तृत जानकारी दी। प्रशिक्षण सात सितंबर तक चलेगा।.
दून दर्पण (देहरादून), 01 Sep. 2005


पहाड़ में महिलाओं की स्थिति का अंदाजा इससे लगाया जा सकता है कि यहां हर महिला को चारे व पानी को हर रोज औसतन 7 कि.मी. का सफर तय करना होता है। इतनी मशक्कत के बाद भी यहां की आर्थिक स्थिति काफी दयनीय है।   एफ.आर.आई. में आयोजितजन-जीवन और वन पर आधारित सेमिनार में टाटा एनर्जी एंड रिसर्च इंस्टीट्यूट के वैज्ञानिक पी.पी. भोजवदे ने कहा कि यहां की खेती और वन टिकाऊ तो है लेकिन बिकाऊ साबित नहीं है। मुख्य अतिथि वन मंत्री नव प्रभात ने कहा कि हमारे लिए गौरव की बात है कि यहां का वन क्षेत्र अन्य राज्यों की तुलना में काफी ज्यादा है। उन्होंने कहा कि यहां आम जनता के सहयोग से बनी वन पंचायतों ने बेहतर कार्य किया, जिससे इन्हें बाद में ज्वाइंट फारेस्ट का नाम दिया गया। यह सच्चाई है कि आज वनों पर जनसंख्या और विकास की वजह से काफी दबाव है। उन्होंने बताया कि सूबे में 12 हजार 500 वन पंचायतें कार्य कर रही है। उन्होंने कहा कि उत्तरांचल देश का पहला ऐसा राज्य है, जहां जनता की भागीदारी से 15 हजार हैक्टेयर भूमि पर वन लगाए गए हैं। स्टाकहोम एनवायरनमेंट के प्रतिनिधि गुरान एजवर्ग ने बताया कि विश्व में वनों के कटाव की स्थिति काफी दयनीय है। जनसंख्या बढ़ने के साथ वनों के हो रहे कटान पर प्रकाश डालते हुए कहा कि अगले दस सालों में पानी की खपत वर्तमान की तुलना में ठीक दुगनी हो जाएगी। वैज्ञानिक भोजवदे ने कहा कि हालांकि, सूबे में वनों का क्षेत्रफल 64 फीसदी के करीब कहा जाता है, लेकिन देखा जाए, तो सूबे में सघन वन क्षेत्र मात्र 8 फीसदी ही है। बी.बी.सी. के प्रोजेक्ट मैनेजर एली हावर ने कहा कि वनों के संरक्षण को गैर सरकारी संस्थाओं का सहयोग लिया जाना चाहिए। उन्होंने कहा कि इसके लिए जरूरी है कि एक तरह का जागरूकता अभियान इसमें चलाया जाए, जिसके लिए गैर सरकारी संस्थाओं और पत्रकारों को एक मंच पर आकर कार्य करना होगा। एफ.आर.आई. के निदेशक एस.एस. नेगी ने एफ.आर.आई. के कार्यों पर प्रकाश डालते हुए कहा कि वन संरक्षण को मात्र एफ.आर.आई. या सरकार अकेले कार्य नहीं कर सकती। प्रदीप मेहता ने सालिड बेस मैनेजमेंट, आर.एल.ई. की नेहा कपूर ने महिला सशक्तीकरण, हरिराम सिंह ने जैविक खेती, सुजाता कौशिक ने पर्यावरण पर अपनी रिपोर्ट भी सेमिनार में रखी। सेमिनार में बी.बी.सी. के केट बटलर और टी.ई.आर.आई. के पौल वर्गीज ने भी विचार रखे।
 
अमर उजाला (देहरादून), 13 Sep. 2005